(page  320)

4.5 ORTHOCOGNITION (Jhana -3)

4.51 General Principles

If creativity is the intuitive level of syntaxic conceptualization of the junction between the ego and the numinous element, the first dawning of complete cognitive understanding we have called orthocognition. Orthocognition is the understanding of the principles enunciated in sections 4.1 on the collective preconscious and the "three illusions" especially those concerning the relationship between the individual ego and the numinous element, and their acceptance as a working hypothesis. Orthocognition is much like Maslow's B-cognition. It is a map of the psychic terrain, and an awareness that such relationships exist. It is the first step in the conscious control of the generalized preconscious. The word is compounded from "ortho" (correct) and cognition (in the Guilford sense) "to know that something exists."

Orthocognition involves the realization and visualization that numinous relationships exist. In other words, orthocognition is like having a correct map of the territory you are traversing in your mind; both would be helpful in not getting lost. While we have coined the word for use mainly with the great and overwhelming relationship between

(page 321)

man's conscious ego and the numinous element, orthocognition in a smaller sense extends to any construct more useful than the one it replaces. Thus, the Copernician theory represents an advance of orthocognition over the Ptolemaic, Mendeleev's Periodic table an advance of orthocognition over the Four Elements theory, and the Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court has many orthocognitive insights over his superstition-ridden friends.

The mere knowledge that something exists, and the correct visualization of one's relationship to it, does much to remove superstitions and fear, and to put one on the right track in thinking.

Orthocognition is no more than this, - a first step in the syntaxic realm. Orthocognition has two aspects: a) knowledge that the numinous element exists, and b) visualization of our relationship to it, and the consequences thereof. Knowledge that the numinous element exists may be expressed in the following hypothesis. It appears to us as:
 

1. An all-powerful, impersonal, immaterial force without characteristics or form and without will;
2. Existing outside of time and space, but available to us as a suggestible medium in a hierarchy of altered states of consciousness;
3. Having responsibility for the welfare and survival of all life generally, and specifically for the development and self-concept of man;
4. Receptive to cognitive will, as is a computer terminal when the proper order is encoded, and executing that will in a machine-like impersonal, uncognized, and sometimes unexpected manner, quickly, accurately, impartially, inexorably, appropriately, elegantly, and completely.
This is essentially the doctrine of the Perennial Philosophy which Happold (1970:20) summarizes as follows:
 
1. The phenomenological world is only a partial reality.
2. Man's nature is such that he can intuit the noumenon.
3. He can therefore develop and eventually identify with Divinity.
4. This process is the chief end of man's life.


Let us imagine that a man has been knocked unconscious and then thrown into a dark dungeon so that when he comes to he is in utter blackness. His successive levels of awareness will provide an analogy to our own developing orthocognition of ultimate reality.
 

At level zero the man is not conscious.
At level one he is barely conscious and does not know where he is.
At level two he is conscious of being somewhere in an enclosed space, but because of his concussion he does not have memory of whence he came.
(page 322)
At level three he has explored his enclosed space and concluded that he is a prisoner within it; moreover he begins to remember that he was once outside.
Finally at level four, he recognizes the fact of his present condition, namely that he is a prisoner in a dungeon whose doors and dimensions he knows. He now remembers fully what freedom is like outside, and is beginning to formulate plans to escape.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Orthocognition follows closely upon recognition of the illusory aspects of time, space, and personality. If the reader will refer to the section on the Three Illusions (4.13) he will see that orthocognition follows as a matter of course from this premise.

Knowledge is power, and orthocognitive knowledge of the relationship between the conscious mind and the numinous element leads at once to power. This power must (like all tools) be used carefully and wisely. Basically the power involves the orthocognitive recognition of our relationship to the numinous element, and our visualization of this relationship as "accomplish" (we use the untensed verb form to impress in the reader's mind that this action "take" place outside of time). Since the action "lie" outside of time in the "durative topocosm" (an infinity of potential events), our visualization of it as having occurred, occurring, and being about to occur provides the nourishment to make the seed idea germinate and manifest in the physical world of space/time. (Notice how similar is the action of the Hopi Indian in the rain dance, when he performs a similar enactive representation to make manifest a hoped-for-future event which is within his heart.)

The application of our relationship to the numinous element, and the consequences thereof, may be visualized in strengthening self-concept in seven vital areas:
 

1. my body and physical health
2. my wealth and possessions
3. my loved ones
4. my work and avocation
5. my interests, associations, and social relationships
6. my creations, my gifts to the society
7. my state, nation, culture, and world, especially regarding peace and prosperity.


Each of these areas represents an expansion of self-concept away from egocentricity in the direction of freedom and altruism. Together they cover the totality of self-concept which in turn (since it represents the ego's view of itself) is directly enriched and nourished by the

(page  323)

numinous element. Hence, as a consequence of our relationship to this impersonal element, we should endeavor each day to visualize whatever aspect of self-concept we want to actualize as already existing now in an ideal state, and needing only our desire and will to become manifest. In other words, this part of orthocognition aids us to bring about the necessary environmental conditions for growth.

Let us be honest enough to admit that orthocognition is a low form of syntaxic conceptualization, for it is tinged with personal and selfish will. This constitutes a danger, especially that we shall be responsible for willing some event which indirectly causes trouble to ourselves or our neighbor. (No responsible person would ever be guilty of directly willing such an event.) We should endeavor to purify our minds from selfish purpose, before such an attempt and ever try to ascend the self-concept scale in visualizing as many concrete conditions at the high end as at the low end. Such scruples also suggest that orthocognition is best practiced along with meditation, which may be much more effective in removing the selfish ego. It is important to realize, however, that orthocognition is distinct from meditation, and that it has a legitimate function of promoting positive reinforcement for our continuing this growth. The laborer in the vineyard has a right to his pay, and we have a right as we progress to be protected and made comfortable in our daily lives (though we must not allow comfort to degenerate into sloth).

While the creative aspects of the mind (which indicate it is part of the noumenon) embrace all nature, the relative ease with which the power to affect the environment may be exercised, is expressed in a hierarchy of self concept going outward from the body image through the phenomenal and environmental selves to successively embrace "my body, my possessions, my relations with my loved ones, my work, my interests, my relations, my creations and my world." The easiest of these to affect and to change is of course, "my self-concept," then come events, things, and finally other persons, society, and the universe.

It is important that we understand the uses and limitations of orthocognition. As one of the initial forms of syntaxic representation of the numinous element, it represents a way station to aid in our developmental progress, not a form to be cherished forever. Specifically it has the disadvantage of looking at the universe in terms of the welfare of the personal ego or self-concept and of the modification of that environment for the benefit of the personal ego. Since the concept of the personal ego is itself an illusion, one may well ask what if any benefits are gained by compounding an illusory process. The interim benefits are that the self-concept develops through

(page 324)

orthocognition from a lesser "my" to a greater "my" (as in going along the hierarchy from "my body" to "my world"). This gradual movement from egocentricity to freedom is truly developmental and encourages ego-diffusion; it also has the advantage of helping the ego to feel secure during such an operation; the reduction of anxiety is a helpful step in such a progression. The danger is the usual one in developmental progress, namely that any one stage may prove so tempting that one willingly remains there instead of pushing on. If there be two roads to reality, one through the desert of self-denial and mortification and the other in a milk-and-honey land of delight, the austere path offers less temptation to dally than the comfortable one. The stages of self-concept interest in orthocognition are stages to be gradually surmounted, for every "my" that ties the ego to ownership or association delays development. The wise man, therefore, will realize orthocognition for what it is, an interim device, particularly suitable for us westerners for the gradual transcendence of self-concept by applying it more and more to the environmental self, and less and less to the personal self.

The power of orthocognition is akin to the power of the dreamer in the lucid dream. Both help us become aware that we are dreaming and that the dream world we inhabit in the daytime is not more real than the dream world we inhabit asleep. Since both are dreams, we may expect that mental causes may change the percepts we "see" awake just as they change the dream percepts. It is this awareness that the perceptual world is not "loose and separate," but a product of collective consciousness and hence, changeable by mental means that is the freeing orthocognitive construct.

We have discussed orthocognition as if it were always a deliberate and conscious attempt at control of the environment through visualization in the syntaxic mode, but we must note for completeness that there are many instances of such visualizations in other modes in which, without realizing that he is doing so, the individual sets in motion the same kind of archetype or mental picture which eventuates in a manifest material state or event.

For the human mind is not merely endowed (as part of the noumenon) with the power to cognize nature, it is also endowed with the power to design nature. The end objective of consciousness is not mere experience but reification. Whether we realize it or not, our thoughts affect the plastic numinous element which tends (unless prevented by other thoughts) to transform these thoughts into events. This is the secret of the self-fulfilling prophecy, for what a man can predict or visualize is (to use Koko's words) "As good as done already." As Pearce (1973:11) states: "Thinking is a shaping force in reality."

(page 325)

Life is like being stunned then put into a strait jacket then dropped from a great height with a parachute. The problem is one first has to come to, then get out of the straitjacket, then activate the parachute. When consciousness is imprisoned in space, time, and personality, it is put into this position. Orthocognition is the first dawning of consciousness that it is in this fix (i.e. like the lucid dreamer that he is having a dream). Then the problem is to get out of the situation and not be beguiled by all of its allurements. Like Apollo, we are set in a great chariot for a swing through the heavens. But will consciousness reap the regard of this journey through space and time, or will there be only the usual Pussycat's report?

Pussycat, pussycat, where have you been?
I've been to London to visitthe Queen.
Pussycat, pussycat what did you there?
I frightened a little mouse underherchair.

When consciousness is encased in creaturehood, it is very difficult not to be about the business of the creature. So after all the effort of going to London we may content ourselves with frightening a little mouse, rather than seeing the Queen.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Blofeld (1970:84) calls orthocognition "visualization" and says of it:

It produces quick results by utilizing forces familiar to man only at the deeper levels of consciousness ... wherewith mind creates and animates the whole universe; ordinarily they are not ours to command, until the false ego is negated or unless we employ yogic means to transcend its bounds. . . .
Since orthocognition involves a realization that the ego rather than being the central aspect of life is something to be transcended, it requires a radical switch in thinking. This from I-thinking" to "not-I-thinking" is made more difficult by the construction of our grammar. But since we can also rise by that which appears to cause our fall, we can deal with this problem grammatically. We can express the triple integral of the ego mathematically by SSSI .  We can hence use the shortened symbol SI to mean the transpersonal noumenon; so that when we say "I visualize," we are more accurate to say (or write) "SI visualize," since only SI is capable of bringing the visualization to manifestation. (see Table X, page 252)

It is sometimes loosely stated than an action taken in the body (orthocognition or a physical ritual, see section 3.5 last 5 paragraphs)

(page 326)

activates a cosmic source, but this is an inaccurate rendition of the event. What happens is that the SI situation takes place outside of time (and hence eternally and recurrently in time), and the calling forth of the function outside of time hence projects the manifestation into time in the here and now and in the future. This process which transforms thought into action can be performed syntaxically through orthocognition by the SI procedure which works in the durative topocosm. It can also be accomplished parataxically through the ritual repetition of a formula which sets up a vibration or cycle. Both processes are like turning on a tap to release a flow of water. They do not produce the water which flows; they merely release it or bring it from posse into esse.

To program one's dreams and to program one's (dreaming awake) normal life are very similar functions. One involves creativity and the other healing; both are orthocognitive. For in both it is SI which brings design to an otherwise chaotic state.

The stages of consciousness in man go from essential animal consciousness (mere reaction to stimuli) to self-consciousness (normal formal operations and some insight) to orthocognition (with its understanding that SI is imprisoned in time, space, and personality). Finally there comes cosmic consciousness which is at first transient in the psychedelic stage and continual in the unitive.

Bruner (1962) is only one of many who have noticed that on logical grounds scientists postulate "empty categories" (like the Hamiltonian quarternions), and then science discovers contents for the category. Teilhard de Chardin pointed out that man's imagination is a creative process which carries on the universe, and Elaide (1959) sees man as free to intervene in the ontological constitution of the universe. Polanyi (1958) speaks of the "indwelled" idea which gestates in material progress. Despite these seers, most of us do not at all appreciate the power of the logos of cognitive syntaxic process in the creative process of the universe, although we have been told authoritatively, "In the beginning was the Word."

Since orthocognition is a form of mental dimensional orientation, it is related to the structure of intellect factor of spatial visualization. The ability to orient oneself in three dimensional space can be developed into the ability to orient oneself outside of space and time, and hence to possess the means for transcending the illusion they present. In the same manner as the lucid dreamer who knows that he is dreaming (and hence gains the capacity to will what he dreams), the person who is orthocognitively aware of his orientation toward ultimate reality also comes to possess the capacity to design his life (to will what he "dreams" awake). A curious corollary of this relationship of

(page  327)

orthocognition to spatial visualization is that the next metaphysical Aufklarung is much more likely to come from scientists, engineers, and architects (all high in spatial relations) than from ministers, social workers, or physicians. The religious man of the future is much more likely to be in the mold of an Einstein or a Heisenberg than of the Pope or a Protestant equivalent.

Since orthocognition represents a correct view of man's relationship to the universe, or cognitive competence in advance of affective feeling, it is in effect an example of a "reverse dysplasia" (Gowan, 1974:168-70)in which the cognitive development leads the affective. These reverse dysplasias, while rare except in the able, offer an unusual opportunity for the cognitive area to "pull" emotional areas into balance with it. They also, in the case of orthocognition at least, "telegraph" the secret of psychedelia which in the past used to be revealed to mystics during an ecstatic grace. This is the meaning of the ending paragraph The Development of  thePsychedelic Individual (Gowan, 1974:251) which indicates that the psychology now has the cognitive capacity to reveal what only mystics could sense affectively.

4.52 Is Orthocognition Moral?

Magic has been defined as the use of universal powers for personal interest and it cannot be denied that orthocognition represents a syntaxic form of magic. Honesty, therefore, compels us to think very carefully whether or not it is a licit procedure. We confess candidly that no other issue in this volume has given us the concern that this one has. The issue is very grave, for if orthocognition is proscribed, then all forms of self-help including the therapies-ministries-religions of auto and mental suggestion, Christian Science, Religious Science, positive thinking, demonstration versus environment, prosperity metaphysics, Coueism, New Thought, hypnosis, Autogenic Training, autohypnosis, psychosynthesis, personality culture, and mesmerism are also illicit.25
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Having reviewed the arguments pro and con in detail, it is our feeling that orthocognition is within the modern view of man's increasing control over himself and his environment. The fission of the atom represents a powerful tool which can be used for good or evil; but no one would suggest that we erase this knowledge from our culture on that account. A similar statement could be made in behalf of orthocognition. If man continues to grow in knowledge, he must continue to grow in the discretion to use that power wisely.

(page 328)

Under the restraints which have been set down in this section, we believe that orthocognition may be innocently employed.

In such a grave issue, we would do well to find more authoritative sources, which fortunately are at hand. Satrem (1968:274) points out that the saint Sri Aurobindo, far from rejecting power, (even though it may often be misused), on the contrary declared that the concept of power - Shakti - is the key to his yoga:
 

It is a mistake ... to condemn Power as in itself a thing not to be accepted or sought because naturally corrupting or evil. ... Power is divine, and put here for divine use.


4.53 Orthocognition Compared

While orthocognition represents a "new" syntaxic procedure, it is not that original. It bears unmistakable relationships to Coueism, Christian Science, New Thought, Religious Science, Positive Thinking, Autogenic Training, Psychosynthesis, and several other movements. In addition, however, there are some earlier views which have such striking similarities as to require special attention.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The first exhibit is the thought of Thomas Troward (1909) which has been somewhat explicated in Chapter 1.

Troward (1909:85) believed that it was perfectly possible to program the preconscious (which he called "subjective mind") from a completely rational state of consciousness without need of dissociation or any altered state. Since he conceived the preconscious to be impersonal, and existing in a subjective hypnotic state, it had no desire of its own, and consequently it waited for us to make up its mind for it. He postulated that:

 
1. There is emotion in the conscious mind which gives rise to
2. Desire;
3. Judgement determines if we shall externalize this desire, if approved,
4. The will directs the imagination to form the necessary prototype;
5. The clutch of the conscious mind is allayed by sleep, hypnotism, satori, or some altered state of consciousness, during which the prototype is transferred from the individual to the general mind (from the personal to the impersonal) (from the conscious to the preconscious); the imagination thus centered now in the preconscious creates the mental (spiritual) nucleus;
6. This prototype in the preconscious is a fact of reality, and, hence,
(page  329)
acts as a center around which the forces of attraction begins to work so that
7. An inward and spiritual fact becomes manifested in outward and perceptible form.


We conceive this process to take place much as a master print in xeroxing has its image transferred via a light beam to a succession of copies of which it is the prototype. The key aspect is the juncture of the conscious desire with the collective preconscious. While it is evident that such a juncture can more easily take place during an altered state of consciousness (such as a hypnopompic state), Troward seems to feel that it can also be affected, at least by some, in the ordinary state.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Our second exhibit is an example of the magic of a primitive culture which has a number of similarities to orthocognition.

Max Freedman Long (Dane, 1974) after a long study of Hawaiian Kahuna magic beliefs determined that their system involved three souls for man:
 

a) the uhane, the spirit that talks (the left hemisphere) conscious mind
b) the unihipili, the "low" mind that does not talk, but makes pictures (the right hemisphere) or the unconscious
c) the aumakua, the parental spirit or spirit guardian (the preconscious -this is the God within man). The form of consciousness that performs the miracles: called by Hawaiians "the High Self."


The Huna belief is that the three spirits are encased by three shadowy bodies composed of a sticky substance called aka. Pranic energy is called mana; it is manufactured by the physical body and is under the control of the low self. It is sent to the higher selves by means of the silver cord which connects the etheric bodies (the aka). For healing much more mana is needed by the High Self and this is accumulated and sent to the High Self through breathing exercises. So for healing the Kahuna makes a mental picture of things as they should be and sends this picture with mana to the High Self. In Hawaiian the word for prayer is hou; this word also means to "pant or breathe heavily." The Hawaiians conceive the High Self to be both male and female and a quasi-sex union between these two aspects creates the new conditions which result in healing. Telepathy, according to the Kahunas, is made up of pictures sent by the low self to the high self. Hence, telepathy and prayer are very similar. It is very interesting that the Kahunas insist on this non-talking property

(page 330)

of the low self in view of the fact that modern psychology has found out that the right hemisphere cannot talk, but is intelligent nevertheless and that it also may have paranormal abilities through the use of pictures and visualization.

4.54 Orthocognition as Healing

The principle of orthocognition, plus the two examples we have given of it lends itself immediately to the application of healing. One might have said "psychic healing" indicating that healing is a kind of siddhi (see section 4.154), but it is becoming abundantly evident that healing is something natural and a power possessed by almost everyone. The differences between the everyday aspects of healing, and the esoteric aspects of levitation, for example, are so great as to require separate consideration, in this section, apart from the rarer siddhis which appear to require some kind of ASC. For healing does not appear to require an ASC. It does require orthocognition, and it seems to be some kind of twin to creativity.

The relationship between this transcendental union of the individual and general minds, and psychic healing, is beautifully stated by Green et al. (1971b):

 
As a final word, it seems increasingly certain that healing and creativity are different pieces of a single picture. Both Swami Rama and Jack Schwarz, a Western Sufi whom we recently had a chance to work with, maintain that self healing can be performed in a state of deep reverie. Images for giving the body instructions are manipulated in a manner very similar to that used by Assagioli for personality and transpersonal integration, as in his Psychosynthesis. But this "manner" of manipulation of images is also the same as that in which we find ideas being handled creatively (by two pilot subjects) for the solution of intellectual problems. What an interesting finding! Creativity in terms of physiological processes means then physical healing, physical regeneration. Creativity in emotional terms consists then of establishing, or creating, attitude changes through the practice of healthful emotions, that is, emotions whose neural correlates are those that establish harmony in the visceral brain, or to put it another way, emotions that establish in the visceral brain those neurological patterns whose reflection in the viscera is one that physicians approve of as stress resistant. Creativity in the mental domain involves the emergency of a new and valid synthesis of ideas, not by deduction, but springing by "intuition" from unconscious sources.
(page 331)
The entrance, or key, to all these inner processes we are beginning to believe, is a particular state of consciousness to which we have given the undifferentiated name "reverie." This reverie can be approached by means of theta brainwave training in which the gap between conscious and unconscious processes is voluntarily narrowed, and temporarily eliminated when useful. When that self-regulated reverie is established, the body can apparently be programmed at will and the instructions given will be carried out, emotional states can be dispassionately examined, accepted or rejected, or totally supplanted by others deemed more useful, and problems insoluable in the normal state of consciousness can be elegantly resolved.

Perhaps now, because of the resurgence of interest in self exploration and in self realization, it will be possible to develop a synthesis of old and new, East and West, prescience and science, using both yoga and biofeedback training as tools for the study of consciousness. It is also interesting to hypothesize that useful parapsychological talents can perhaps be developed by use of these reverie-generating processes of yoga and biofeedback. Much remains to be researched, and tried in application, but there is little doubt that in the lives of many people a penetration of consciousness into previously unconscious realms (of mind and brain) is making understandable and functional much that was previously obscure and inoperable.
 

It is also interesting to recollect that there seem to be three kinds of healers:
 
(a) those whose healing power is emitted through the hands,26 prototaxically
(b) those whose healing power depends upon images formed in the right high hemisphere (such as the "low mind" of the kahunas) in which there is a parataxic level of effect; and
(c) those whose healing power is operated syntaxically, through the word (Jesus: "Stretch forth thy hand," Luke, 6:10).


We do not include acupuncture as an aspect of psychic healing because it appears to us to be another school of medicine which deals with the adjustment of energies in the etheric body via the chakra centers. That this operation depends upon a body of knowledge and belief which is not compatible with western medicine as presently practiced is not perjorative in our view; it simply says something about Western thought in general, which is that whether religious, nationalistic, or scientific, it is insufferably arrogant. There is little to choose between the Catholic dictum that it is the only true religion;

(page 332)

the British Empire view that it is the only true state, and the view of modern medicine that it is the only true prophylactic. Thus, despite the availability of a good deal of research evidence to the validity of acupuncture, we shall not examine it, as outside the scope of this investigation.

It is suggestive and interesting that in addition to the ancient tradition of spiritual healing within the Christian Church (such as "laying on of hands,") and its modern emphasis (in such religions as Christian and Religious Science), there should be at the present time, such a tremendous interest in psychic healing particularly by those in the more "respectable" sciences. Thus in a convention sponsored by the Academy of Parapsychology and Medicine (Tiller, 1972) one finds twelve of fourteen speakers with their doctorates. The work done in this area by the Greens of the Menninger Clinic, Professor Tiller of Stanford, Sister M. J. Smith, the biologist, Thelma Moss, the UCLA Kirlian photographer, and A. Puharich is well known and testifies to the academic prestige of the researchers. The literature in this area alone is so voluminous and so recent, that we cannot hope to notice it systematically, but is has progressed from a mere examination and cataloguing of effects to the development of theory, some of which promises to open the doors of our perception.

Let us particularly note that while orthocognitive healing has some similarities to the prototaxic healing enjoyed in trance "heat" and in shamanistic phenomena, it is very much different in the fact that it is accomplished in a normal state of consciousness, and seems indeed, to be more like the intuitive relationship with the preconscious which characterizes creative openness than it does even with the higher forms of ecstasy which we shall later note.

As we noted in section 4.154, the essence of psychic healing is a speed-up in time of what would normally be accomplished in a much longer period. What we are really witnessing, therefore, is the acceleration of chemical reactions. If ultimate reality exists outside of time, and if orthocognition is the dawning recognition of this fact, the consequent psychic healing as an accelerated physical process would follow immediately upon this principle.

4.6 MEDITATION (Jhana -2)

4.61 General Information

Meditation represents the last procedure and the highest level of the creative stage. Unlike all other procedures, it involves a conscious effort to open the doors to the preconscious, through clearing and

(page 333)

tranquilizing the conscious mind. Meditation is not prayer, for it does not involve importuning an external Deity. As Christian Humphreys (1968:6) remarks: "At best the method of prayer is a yearning of the heart; meditation, on the other hand, reorients the mind. . . . "

The basic principle involved in the use of meditation as an enhancement to self-awareness and as a stimulation to growth is its syntaxic contact with the numinous element; this contact involves:
 

(1) the manifestation of the numinous in a positive and controlled form,
(2) the "entasy"27 (or full normal consciousness) of the ego, which results in the benefit of learning from the experience, and
(3) the tranquilization of the cogitative aspects of the mind, so that one gradually becomes conscious of its "openness" rather than its "connectedness", and of ideas flowing into it, rather than ideas being churned up by it.


Meditation sets one consciously on the path of yoga, or union with the numinous, but since meditation is a transitional procedure between the creative and the psychedelic stage, the motivations of the person embarking upon it experience subtle and often rapid changes. The Indian saint Sri Aurobindo understood this yogic development well. Satprem (1968:34) quotes Sri Aurobindo as follows:
 

One may start a process of one kind or another for the purpose which would normally mean a long labor, and be seized, even at the outset, by a rapid intervention of manifestation of Silence with an effect all out of proportion to the means used at the beginning. One commences with a method but the work is taken up by a Grace from above. . .
Satprem (Ibid.) continues:
 
... yoga awakens automatically ... a whole gamut of latent faculties ... which can do for us that of which we are normally incapable. (Quoting Sri Aurobindo) "One has to have the passage clear between the outer mind and something in the inner being ... for ... the yogic consciousness and its powers are already there within you," and the best way of clearing is to make the mind silent. We do not know who we are and still less what we are capable of.


Satprem (1968:35-6) points out that meditation is only the beginning of the psychedelic life:
 

But the practice of meditation is not the true solution of the problem (though it be quite necessary at the beginning to give the push) because we shall attain perhaps a relative silence, but
(page 334)
at the very moment we put our foot outside our room or our retreat we shall fall back. . . .
The extra need is for "a complete life" so that we can practice silence "in the street," and become "oriented."

While there are many specific techniques of meditation, they all appear to have some common elements. The key factors facilitating meditation appear to be:

1) relaxing the body, and rendering the mind insensible to it by:
    a) sitting upright in a relaxed posture,
    b) shutting the eyes,
    c) being undisturbed in a quiet, shuttered room,
    d) controlling the breath so that one breathes more slowly and shallowly;

2) relaxing the mind, and bringing it to an altered state of consciousness by:
    a) use of a mantra (or repetition of the same words, sound or tone),
    b) exclusion of distracting thoughts from the mind,
    c) developing a simple "awareness" without being consciously attracted to any particular idea or wish.


The aim is a "relaxed awareness," but in the words of Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, one should perform meditation "without expectation of any results," not in the anticipation of a psychedelic experience. Or as another teacher has put it, "we don't evaluate the results of meditation by our subjective experience, but in the happiness and efficiency of our lives." The benefits of meditation are stressed as relaxation and rest, rather than as an indubitable pathway to the nature-mystic-peak experience, (although such experiences may occur). Aldous Huxley (1945:283) talks about a very similar technique of the Christian mystics in which prayer begins with mental concentration on Christ's passion, and then passes from it to the formless substratum. He notes a similar experience from the Tibetian Book of the Dead:

 
Whosoever thy tutelary deity may be, meditate upon the form for much time - as being apparent, yet non-existent in reality, like a form produced by a magician.. . Then let the visualization of the tutelary deity melt away from the extremities, till nothing at all remaineth visible of it; and put thyself in the state of the Clearness and the Voidness - which thou canst not conceive as something - and abide in that state for a little while. Again meditate upon the tutelary deity; again meditate upon the Clear Light; do this alternately. Afterwards allow thine own intellect to melt away gradually, beginning from the extremities.


Huxley (1945:290) also quotes Ashvaghosha on the Way of Tranquillity as follows:

Those who are practising 'stopping' should retire to some quiet
(page 335)
place and there, sitting erect, earnestly seek to tranquillize and concentrate the mind. While one may at first think of one's breathing, it is not wise to continue this practice very long, nor to let the mind rest on any particular appearances, or sights, or conceptions, arising from the senses.

All kinds of ideation are to be discarded as fast as they arise; even the notions of controlling and discarding are to be got rid of. One's mind should become like a mirror, reflecting things, but not judging them or retaining them. Conceptions of themselves have no substance; let them arise and pass away unheeded. Conceptions arising from the senses and lower mind will not take form of themselves, unless they are grasped by the attention; if they are ignored, there will be no appearing and no disappearing. The same is true of conditions outside the mind; they should not be allowed to engross one's attention and so to hinder one's practice. The mind cannot be absolutely vacant, and as the thoughts arising from the senses and the lower mind are discarded and ignored, one must supply their place by right mentation. The question then arises: what is right mentation? The reply is: right mentation is the realization of mind itself, of its pure undifferentiated Essence. When the mind is fixed on its pure Essence, there should be no lingering notions of the self, even of the self in the act of realizing, nor of realization as a phenomenon. . . .


A number of mechanical devices have been used to secure a "free-floating" state which is conscious but passive, and which gives attention inward to thought processes as they form in the mind, and attempts to go beyond them into pure consciousness. This requires narrowing the attention, restricting sensory input, and cutting down on the inpouring of random stream of consciousness ideas. Techniques used to bring about this state may involve chanting, giving attention to one's breathing, gazing into a mandala (sacred picture), mentally repeating a mantra, concentrating on a koan, or other similar process all designed to fix and tranquilize the attention.

Some systems such as Zen are rather prescriptive about methods used to induce what Christian mystics would call their "Prayer of Quiet," while others, such as Transcendental Meditation are quite permissive. Such differences suit different temperaments, and all may be useful under various circumstances. Some such as hatha yoga and Nichiren Shoshu are mainly somatic, while others, such as raja yoga are mainly cerebral. But all of these methods attempt to deal with quieting the constant inrush of distracting thoughts and percepts

(page 336)

which appear to sustain the normal state of consciousness, and without which it lapses into sleep, or another ASC.

There seem to be two levels to meditation which blend into one another. In the lower level, meditation is an effort to avoid distractions such as the stream-of-consciousness babble. The slightest external noise disrupts; as John Donne (1626) said:
 

I throw myself down in my chamber, and I call and invite God and his angels thither, and when they are there, I neglect God and his angels for the noise of a fly, for the rattling of a coach, or the whining of a door.


In the higher level, these distractions cease; meditation is a joy, and "the Prayer of Quiet," (jhana-1), is reached. Meditation hence becomes the bridge between the creative and the psychedelic stages.

Barbara Brown (1974) believes that while alpha biofeedback is not necessary for the advanced meditator, it may be useful for the beginner, in helping him to track onto alpha (which of course prevents distractions). Nideffer (Shapiro and others 1972:167-185) in a comprehensive review of alpha and the development of human potential including meditation, agrees with Brown, and concludes that biofeedback may have an important future in "maximizing psychological functioning" at all levels of the creative stage. Green of the Menninger clinic (ibid:152ff) finds biofeedback useful in both healing and creativity after a series of experiments. The net effect of all this testimony is that biofeedback is a helpful procedure for advancement in the syntaxic mode, useful for establishing both creativity and meditation.

For the purpose of advancement in the syntaxic mode, Progoff (1968) advocates the keeping of what he calls an "intensive journal." It is a psychological notebook, designed "to help achieve an experience crucial in the process of personal growth", namely the initiation of an "enlargement of consciousness." This process helps the individual to reach "a direct contact with the creative principle which is at the core of life." Besides the daily log there are meditational and orthocognitive experiences designed both to accomplish therapeutic "unstressing" and positive growth toward self- actualizing behavior. Progoff counsels that the intensive journal should be used in concert with group workshops, etc.

Constituted as structure for the growth process, the intensive journal is a directed log of areas where the individual is to write daily. The areas are as follows:
 

1. Describe the characteristics of the most recent period of your life including emotions, dreams, unusual events, feelings.
2. Same analysis of the present day.
(page 337)
3. Personal sections to include dialogue with people, dialogue with books and other works, group experiences, dialogue with events, dialogue with the body.
4. Depth contact (ways of gaining access to one's personal potentials): dreams, dream enlargements, hypnagogic imagery and fantasy, extensions of same, inner dialogues;
5. Life history log or rememberings and recapitulations: stepping stones, intersections, Now (and the Future). As one keeps reevaluating the choice points (stepping stones) one finds that they move from the exterior events to inner events, and change markedly in a process of expansion.28


Meditation can be considered as a take-off point beyond ortho-cognition because it readies the individual for the cognitive experience of altered states of awareness or consciousness.

Meditation allows the person, through contemplative self awareness or "going within" to more directly experience his higher self nature. Awareness of the numinous element is enhanced during the meditative process. And the relationship of the higher self to the numinous element is further realized, where the paradox of subject and object can later be transcended in a unity of "being." 29

In considering the following forms of meditation it should also be realized that, in some of them, this process of continued experience of higher levels of consciousness is the only means of true self realization. It is considered to be the means of transcending the illusion of separateness at ordinary states of consciousness, experiencing the inner reality of higher self and moving upward to essence and unity of "being." We return again to the merging of higher self and the numinous element beyond time, space and personality, to a full cognition of the all by the all-the unity of Atman and Brahman, the attainment of Buddha nature.

4.62 Nichiren Shoshu29

Nichiren Shoshu is a sect of Buddhist philosophy based upon an interpretation of the Lotus Sutras. The process of meditation in Nichiren Shoshu is practiced by the individual alone or in group meetings, or both. The recommended length of time according to its practitioners is two hours per day.

Meditation begins with a ceremonial practice of candle lighting, then chanting to the Gohonzon is begun. The Gohonzon is considered to have been divinely inspired when it was written and endowed with great power. This power can be brought into effect for the benefit of the chanter through faith and continued chanting. It is claimed that the laws of cause and effect which operate at all levels of existence

(page 338)

are brought into play through chanting. Even though the words chanted repeatedly are in Japanese and are not cognitively understood, it is felt that because they are in tune with a universal energy force and are used in conjunction with belief in the Gohonzon that the results will be beneficial.

In terms of human growth, the philosophy is that chanting will awaken the higher self nature in man, regardless of his initial intent in chanting, and that he will improve as a person to higher levels of self awareness and cognitive growth. It is also stressed that the individual will be happy due to receiving benefits from chanting, and that world peace can be achieved through expanded individual happiness.

Even though discipline through regular practice of chanting is stressed, there is no emphasis upon a guru for each student nor upon asceticism of any kind. In fact just the opposite is true, for the stress is on joy and happiness attained through the receipts of benefits from chanting. Nichiren Shoshu appeals on the average to a younger group of followers than one might find in Zen or Vedanta for example. This may be due to the fact that the positive feelings connected with the solidarity of the organization, and the athletic strivings for world peace, help provide a channel for the outlet of energy and the need for belonging characteristic of adolescents. It may also provide a reinforcement of positive identity for those who have not yet internalized the identity issue at the higher level of self.

Compared with other forms of meditation, Nichiren Shoshu appears to resemble the syntaxic procedure of orthocognition. There is more emphasis on a kind of visualization of positive conditions, surrounding and affecting self-concept. This action is understandable for adolescents who at the time of the identity crisis are not perhaps ready for the higher psychedelic states of consciousness. Like other forms of meditation, then, Nichiren Shoshu is a preparation for mystic experience. The beneficial effects of chanting as facilitating "unstressing" (section 2.23) should not be minimized.

4.63 Transcendental Meditation

"Transcendental Meditation is a systematic procedure of turning the attention inward toward the subtler levels of thought until the mind transcends the experience of the subtlest state of thought and arrives at the source of the thought." "TM is a purely mental technique practiced individually every morning and evening for fifteen to twenty minutes at a sitting. It requires no alteration of life style, diet, etc. and as a technique of direct experience rather than a religion or philosophy, it does not require belief in the efficacy of the practice

(page 339)

nor an understanding of the underlying theory. Wallace and others (1971) have characterized it as a "wakeful hypometabolic physiologic state," i.e., a state of restful alertness. TM is apparently a universal human faculty, not requiring any particular intellectual or cognitive facility other than the ordinary ability to think. It is easily learned by anyone in about six hours of instruction, spread out over four consecutive days from a Maharishi-trained teacher. Once learned, it can be continued without the necessity for additional instruction.*

Another "American" aspect of the packaging of Transcendental Meditation is the great interest its exponents have shown in psychological research and evaluation. Seldom, if ever, has a "cult" shown such concern about scientific accountability. Despite its recent introduction, the continued practice of transcendental meditation has been shown to:

 
1. reduce anxiety (Wallace 1970, Doucette, 1972)
2. improve learning (Abrams, 1972, Shaw and Kolb, 1970)
3. improve accuracy of percepts (Blasdell, 1971)
4. increase energy and reduce need for sleep (Wallace, 1970)
5. increase mental health (Fehr, 1972) (Goleman, 1971) (Seeman, 1972), (Kanellakos, et al., 1972)
6. reduce blood pressure, respiratory rate, and oxygen intake (Allison, 1970), Wallace, et al., 1971), (Wallace, et al.,1972)
7. reduce drug-abuse dependence (Benson, 1969, 1970), (Williams, 1972), (Winquist, 1969)
8. decrease hostility (Bose and Berger, 1972)
9. increase alpha wave production (Brown, et al., 1972).


But TM has been packaged for American tastes in more subtle ways. One of its dictates is that practitioners should not meditate more than fifteen to twenty minutes twice per day, and the occasional longer meditations should be undertaken only under supervision.

The practice of Transcendental Meditation (TM) is an outgrowth of Hindu tradition, developed by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi from the teachings of guru Dev under whom he studied for many years. The practice itself begins with the training of each participant. It is not required that the individual conform to strict disciplinary rules in terms of alteration of life style, nor is there an emphasis on asceticism involved. The instructor is a trained teacher who studied under the guidance of the Maharishi himself, but contrary to more formal Hindu teaching such as Vedanta, the student gradually lessens contact with the teacher as he becomes more proficient in the practice.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*This paragraph consists of a series of quotes from Levine, P., 1972. The first sentence is quoted from Maharishi, 1969.

(page 340)

The training involves the presentation of a mantra or meaningless sound to the student which is only described as a vehicle that allows meditation to take place. The next step in the training is described "sitting upright in a chair with eyes closed, the student listens to his mantra as it is chanted by his teacher, and then takes it up himself - first aloud, and then silently.... Meditators appear for all practical purposes to be asleep. Yet they say their minds remain acutely aware of outside stimuli. . . . "

After the initial four lessons the student practices the meditation on his own on a twice daily basis for 15-20 minutes per session. The state arrived at during this process has been described as a wakeful hypo-metabolic physiologic state in which the nervous system naturally goes about normalizing the existing tensions and discords, biochemical and physiologic abnormalities. With the regular practice of this restful psychophysiologic experience the spontaneous occurring result is improved physiologic functioning, increased psychophysiologic stability, and improved psychological integration.

The studies are too numerous to go into detail here, but for further references one is directed to: "The Psychobiology of Transcendental Meditation: A Literature Review," Kanellakos and Zukas (1973). Briefly however, in terms of physiological changes, the Stanford Research Institute Review stated: "The physiological correlates of TM - and some of the meditational states reached by other techniques - appear to define a lowered metabolic state characterized by decreased autonomic activity, decreased emotional and sensory reactivity, decreased muscle tension, and a wakeful, alert brain."

Despite the fact that there is an initiation fee for TM, (the money goes to support the organization's research, educational, and recruiting operations), the movement has been very successful both in the United States and abroad. Various world centers, including the Maharishi International University (at the site of former Parsons College in Fairfield, Iowa) have been set up. Practitioners are supposed to number over 500,000 in the U.S. alone.
Because of its interest in research, its non-insistence on a creed, and its adaptation to American life styles, it seems of all forms of meditation, perhaps the easiest for most Westerners to pursue.

4.64 Psychocatalysis: The Foundation of Human Understanding29

The Foundation of Human Understanding was founded by Roy Masters, who is still its president and most authoritative, outspoken proponent of the meditation exercise and underlying philosophy.

Masters developed the meditation exercise in the early 1960's and is the sole official instructor of the technique which is presented

(page 341)

to the student on a set of records along with an accompanying book entitled "How Your Mind Can Keep You Well." In each of these the student is guided through the meditation practice, and at the same time presented with the underlying philosophy espoused by the organization. Some individuals who have practiced the technique for several years have criticized the practice of presenting beliefs to the student during meditation. They claim that it runs contradictory to the purpose of meditation itself to install beliefs externally during meditation. Some have even claimed that it borders on an hypnotic process. Masters has defended this procedure claiming that he is only reinforcing deeper truths regarding dynamics of human behavior and that the individual is in a state of conscious awareness and not in an hypnotic trance.

The meditation process, which is performed by the individual alone after several beginning sessions with the record, is practiced twice daily for approximately 15minutes per session.

In very basic terms it involves sitting or lying quietly and centering the concentration on the center of the forehead. Contrary to the process of TM, however, in this form of meditation the object is not to still the mind through the imposition of a mantra. Instead, the individual is to observe his thought without being caught up in thought or holding on to a particular idea.

Masters (1971) calls this technique "Psychocatalysis" and describes it as a combination of "some of the concentration techniques of ancient Yoga with the sound logic of Judeo-Christian principles." He sees the process of the meditation exercise as a "Subjection of mind, feeling, and body, to the dictates of inner reality; the technique by which the consciousness is 'raised' to the level of observation."

4.65 Arica 29

The Arica Institute was founded in 1970 by Oscar Ichazo, a South American who has combined the diverse areas of religion, esoteric mysticism, and psychology. Through years of experience he developed a holistic approach to human development based upon the elimination of barriers to positive states of consciousness. These barriers to higher levels of consciousness, according to Ichazo (Keen, 1973), are the result of ego-dominated thought which he feels prevents transcendence to the realization of higher self nature (or as he calls it 'essence') and accompanying cognitive growth.

The eclectic techniques he has developed deal with three basic areas which he considers extensions of this ego-dominated thought. These areas are body, emotion, and intellect.
A detailed analysis of the techniques used to eliminate barriers

(Page 342)

in each of these three areas would be too lengthy and complex to be included here. But generally they include:

1)  exercises based upon Hatha Yoga and Aikido for the purpose of overcoming "body ego" and reaching the Kath or spontaneous flowing of movement,
2) exercises designed to attain a "biological understanding of objective virtue" (Keen, 1973)leading to a harmonious emotional life and
3) meditation and chanting exercises designed to eliminate the barrier of intellect and transcend it to higher levels of consciousness where there can be a syntaxic communicating of deeper meanings of inner reality.
This last area of meditation and chanting is of particular interest here since its purpose is the experience of higher levels of consciousness in a syntaxic manner. And while Ichazo emphasizes the destructive aspect of ego more than is the case with the previous forms of meditation (with the exception of psychocatalysis) the similarity lies in the emphasis on higher levels of consciousness toward the level of the nature mystic experience and beyond. In fact Ichazo has numbered various "states of consciousness," adapting it from the Gurdjieff chart of vibration levels, which is organized in ascending and descending order from the highest positive level to the lowest negative level. A description of each level is given by Lilly (1972) (p. 148) in relationship to both the Gurdjieff levels and those of Hindu philosophy.

These levels of consciousness are experienced by nearly everyone at sometime, but it is the ability to map and integrate these experiences in the syntaxic mode of communicating deeper meaning that produced growth at the cognitive level. And in terms of its interdependent relationship with affective development, increasingly profound understanding of inner reality must take place along with ego transcendence to a higher self realization and reorganization of identity in that respect.

4.66 Zen29

Zen is another branch of Buddhism and consists of several schools emphasizing different areas of practice. In terms of Buddhist philosophy, it is interesting to compare the extreme difference in emphasis and practice between Nichiren Shoshu and Zen. In the former there is no emphasis on initial intent, need for a guru, or hard work and a strictly disciplined life style to achieve the goal of understanding the self and attaining Buddahood. In Zen the emphasis is indeed on these things. In Nichiren Shoshu the initial attraction seems to be the attainment of desired things which will make the person happy and reinforce belief. In Zen the attraction seems to be the striving for understanding of self and stimulation of the developmental process

(page 343)

through disciplined practice, which eventually will lead to a real joy and happiness for the individual. Whereas discomfort is not emphasized in Nichiren Shoshu, in Zen the student may be purposely exposed to it for the purpose of breaking down "mind sets" and transcending the intellect.

This transcendence of the intellect to a syntaxic experience of inner reality at higher levels of consciousness is the basic thrust of Zen in terms of cognitive development. In terms of affective development, it is the transcendence of ego to identification with higher self nature. The merging of the two comes in the attainment of Buddahood which seems to be a development of self toward identification and unity with the numinous element.

The whole process of Zen meditation is directed toward a life style of affective and cognitive development designed to answer the question "Who am I?" As Suzuki puts it; "When you ask what Zen is, I say that Zen is you and you are Zen. The questioner is the answerer. Before you ask somebody outside what Zen is, you turn inwardly and ask, who am I?" (p. 18-19).

Turning inwardly is the practice of Zen meditation. It is practiced in a very disciplined manner under the direction of a Roshi or Master who guides the student's progress, providing challenges and offering encouragement.

The meditation may be viewed under four headings according to Humphreys (1971); 1) Continuity - the regular practice of meditation, 2) Zazen - Zen sitting wherein the student meditates upon a subject given him by the Roshi or Master, 3) Koan and Mundo - The Koan is a word, phrase or saying which defies intellectual analysis and thereby enables the user to burst the fetters of conceptual thought. The Mundo is a rapid exchange of question and answer between master and student, and 4) Satori - the intuitive looking into the nature of things.

Through the experiential process of Zen in the preceding manner, the dualistic intellectual process operating within ordinary states of consciousness is strained to the point of exposing its inability to understand the nature of inner reality through analysis. This inner reality is considered to have its own set of laws which transcend time, space, and personality and which consist of seeming paradoxes to ordinary intellectual process. An example of the paradox of inner reality is the statement by Suzuki (1957) that "In Buddhist Emptiness there is no time, no space, no becoming, no-thing-ness; it is what makes all these things possible; it is a zero full of infinite possibilities, it is a void of inexhaustible contests." (P. 30).

This inner reality with its seeming paradoxical relationships can

(page 344)

only be understood by breaking through to higher levels of consciousness where there is a movement inward from creativity through mystical experience to enlightenment.

The growth process concurrently toward enlightenment and realization of higher self nature is many times referred to in Zen as attaining the Unattainable. It is considered such because it is beyond intellectual analysis and must be experienced. It is also considered such because it is a movement away from dualism toward unity, a movement from a turmoil of illusion to a reality of "Emptiness" and peace. Suzuki (1971) speaks of the intellect and its role in Zen in "attaining the unattainable" as follows: "Zen never despises intellection as such, but it wants intellection to know its place and not to go beyond the sphere it properly belongs to.

4.67 Vedanta29

In basic terms, Vedanta is perhaps the trunk of the tree from which all of the previous forms have branched. It sprung from ancient Hindu philosophy and demonstrates the very nature of Indian philosophy itself. According to Rao (1966) the nature of this philosophy " . . . is the search for an experience of Reality. The subject-matter of Indian philosophy, however, is not the entire reality. It is more, the true nature of the self." (p. 33). This emphasis on the true understanding of self as the key to reality is basic to the Vedantic striving for emancipation from ignorance. The concern for an accurate perception of self as a basis for understanding internal and external reality and for growth is of critical importance.

The Vedanta philosophy and meditative practice (which is an experiential validation of the philosophy) are derived from the teachings of three principle texts: 1) the Upanishads, 2) the Bhagavad Gita, and 3) the Vedanta Sutras.

The fundamental principle involved in the teachings according to Denssen (1906) is that Brahman (the eternal principle of all being, which creates and sustains all worlds and absorbs them) is identical with the Atman, the self or soul (our true essence when judged rightly). This soul is not a part of Brahman, but it is fully and entirely the eternal indivisible Brahman itself. In order to experience this "divine" nature (or higher self nature) within the individual he must "go within" through meditation.

The method which is chosen for meditation can vary depending upon the individual and is determined by the guru. The guru is extremely important in Vedanta meditation and performs a similar function to the Zen Master in guiding the student in his development. He also maintains a position of high respect for his exemplary life

(page 345)

style. However, in contrast to the Zen Master, the guru in Vedanta reinforces the experiential development of the student with teachings from the three principle texts. The purpose for this seems to be to give the student a framework from which to direct his daily life and to point the intellect toward thoughts of a higher nature. This is so that as his experience validates these teachings he continues to evolve in both affective and cognitive areas and does not continue to accumulate Karma due to improper actions along the way.

In Vedanta the guru recognizes that there are many paths to the goal of emancipation from unreality and therefore the Mantra, object, or technique of meditation may vary for each student based upon the one the guru deems best suited to the student.

As a reflection of its philosophy of dispelling external illusion and experiencing inner reality, according to Denssen (1906), Vedanta meditation stresses the " . . . withdrawing of the organs of sense from everything external and in concentrating them upon one's own inner nature." (p. 8). In comparison with the previous forms of meditation this "withdrawing" may be seen as emphasizing the existence of reality only at higher levels of consciousness and being rather than the existence of reality at varying levels of consciousness. This latter emphasis is seen as an illusion.

The process of meditation taught by the guru is intended to allow the student to validate the truth of the guru's teachings and thereby acquire true knowledge of reality. In fact true knowledge is considered the means of emancipation in Vedanta. Acquiring true "knowledge" in Vedanta can be likened to the syntaxic experience of higher levels of consciousness in the cognitive area and contact with higher self nature in the affective area as seen in the previous forms of meditation.

4.68 Integral Yoga

We have seen that the procedures of the creative stage become steadily more cerebral. It is true even of the various forms of meditation. Tantric and hatha yoga, for example, depend considerably upon physical and somatic aspects. Integral Yoga, by contrast, does not. It was discovered and developed by Sri Aurobindo (Ghose), a brilliant and fiery Indian nationalist and contemporary of Gandhi's who took honors at Oxford, and later was imprisoned for agitating for Indian Independence. Renouncing politics, in the 1920's he established an ashram at Pondicherry, India, where as a persuasive writer and religious leader, he became famous for his cognitive approach.30

Sri Aurobindo taught that it was possible for the conscious ego to receive the numinous element and yet retain consciousness if certain rules were followed. His method avoids the "trance" aspects of samadhi,

(page 346)

and de-emphasizes the "ecstatic" aspects of mystic experience. First purification and meditation in an ashram is necessary. Then as his biographer Satprem (1968:38-9) tells us, comes one of the first signs of enlightenment - the "descent of the force."

We feel around the head and more particularly at the nape of the neck an unusual pressure which may give the sensation of a false headache. At the beginning we cannot endure it for long and shake it off, we seek distraction.... Gradually this pressure takes a more distinct form, and we feel a veritable current which descends (i.o.). . . .


This is the start of the integral yoga of Aurobindo, a pranic force which descends the spine instead of ascending it like the kundalini. According to Aurobindo this method results in no ecstatic moments, but better, complete cognition at all times. "The physical effect is almost exactly that of walking in the breeze."

As this process continues (Satprem, 1968:40-1) one becomes like "a solid cool block of peace." One experiences the descent of Shakti as a vast aquamarine blueness and an indescribable coolness (for it is endothermic, not exothermic like the psychic heat of the rising kundalini).31

The next effect (Satprem, 1968:42) is the emergence of a new mode of knowledge. One noticeable sign that order is surfacing in the lives of those who are well along this path is the appearance of a phenomenon we will define as synergy. Synergy occurs in at least two forms. First there is synergy within the individual who is ready for enlightenment; it is commonly found in those who have firmly established the creative routine. It depends upon the fact that while the human mind can attend to only one idea at a time, cosmic mind can attend to a great many (much like a shared-time computer). What happens is that one day, one finds oneself witnessing the fact that a number of things are going on in consciousness, all at the same time. Instead of conflict, however, all these discrete matters are managed harmoniously and effectively. The concept of the witness is an important one of which many occult writers speak.

As Sri Aurobindo puts it (Satprem, 1968:45) "The mind is not an instrument of knowledge, but only an organizer of knowledge." It should be noted that synergy, like other effects in this area is anti-entropic, that is, it contributes to order, not disorder.

In the creative stage, this universal mind (the collective preconscious) leaked creative ideas to the conscious ego (as though by osmosis through a permeable membrane) so that the ego is suffered to think that the ideas are its own. But as one becomes more creative verging

(page 347)

towards the next stage, one has "openings" wherein the ego consciousness is allowed to enter the enlarged domain of the preconscious: the doors of Aladdin's cave are thrown open, and the ego is dazzled by what it finds therein, which it recognizes as coming from outside its own narrow confines. (This is the witness level.)
Having found out (says Satprem, 1968:47) not only
 

. . . that the thoughts of others come to us from the outside, but that our own thoughts also come to us in the same way from outside ... when we are sufficiently transparent, we can feel in the silent immobility of the mind, little swirling eddies which draw our attention ...


we have caught a mental vibration before it has had time to enter and rise to our conscious so that we would perceive it as "my thought."

This extension of empathy is the key to reading the thoughts of others, and to the concept of synergy which we have been discussing. The mental transparency on occasion allows us to visualize more easily, which strengthens our orthocognitive processes, and may allow us to predict, heal or scry. It may also occasionally allow us (in the manner of TV chromokeying32) to see superimposed on the physical reality we are in, another superphysical or psychic and separate reality which appears momentarily and then fades away (just like the superimposed chromokeyed TV picture of the news event appears behind the news commentator as he discusses it, and then fades away).

The second concept of synergy has to do with activities between individuals. For with similarly advanced individuals, instead of responding with the usual difficulties and entropy which a bunch of individual minds might be supposed to cause, these individuals (as though polarized by some external magnet), all seem to operate harmoniously like the constituent parts of a unified social body. This enormously reduces the waste time and effort which would otherwise result from the random operation between these individuals.33

A third concept is the "witness phenomenon," which was also mentioned as the last effect sometimes seen in highly creative individuals (section 4.37m). It is the result of the full preparation of the mind, having been stilled and quieted, to receive its cosmic guest.

Satprem (1968:43) points out that this ability to sustain a bit of the silence even in the workaday world leads to an important step:
 

He will have discovered the Witness (i.o.) in himself and will let himself be captured less and less by the exterior play which ... tries to swallow us alive.
(page 348)

Satprem quotes Sri Aurobindo (1968:78) on what western psychologists would call "dasein-choosing" in regard to untoward life events:
 

Is it not possible that the soul itself ... has accepted and chosen these things as part of its development in order to get through the necessary experience at a rapid rate ... even at the cost of damage to the outward life. . . . To the spirit within us may not difficulties ... be a means of growth ... ?


Satprem (1968:94) identifies this inner fire as "Agni:" "the self of fire," "the only true 'I' in us." The Katha Upanishad is quoted:

"A conscious being is in the center of the self, who rules past and future; he is like a fire without smoke."
The individual who in the syntaxic mode is psychedelically in command of his environment through such techniques as meditation and orthocognition is in a similar circumstance to the individual having the lucid dream: both are aware that the environment in which they appear to find themselves is but a dream; both are aware that this environment can be changed by the individual will.

4.69 Conclusion

1. Meditation is the final procedure, so at this point we are able to draw conclusions about meditation, about the creative stage, and about procedures in general. As the highest procedure of the creative stage, meditation is fully cognitive and syntaxic, but curiously enough the mind is not exercised, it is stilled. For meditation clearly looks ahead to an infusion which is both super-rational and transpersonal. This stilling of the mind in preparation for something to come, - his cleaning of the house and setting it in order to receive an important guest - this process is the hallmark of all meditational forms.

2. Meditation also involves some kind of purification of the senses, reduction of perceptual intake, avoidance of thoughts which are gross and sordid. It involves a change in attentional shift, from concepts built on percepts to prathahara (withdrawal of the mind from sensory percepts). It has some kind of cleansing quality.

3. Unlike creativity which seeks a social response to solve a problem, and orthocognition, which seeks some personal relief or benefit, meditation seeks no product beyond itself. It therefore is the only procedure to gain independence from the ego.

4. Table XI compares the various forms of meditation, with the anchor points of humanistic therapy on the lower end, and mysticism (the next stage) on the upper. It will be seen that while most forms of meditation reflect some adaptation of Vedic principles, they differ with respect to dogma, guru, discipline, objectives, and participants.

(page 349)

Table XI Comparison Between Various Forms of Meditation

(page 350)

It appears that in some way not fully understood as yet, creativity may be a substitute for at least some of the activities of meditation. Both appear to have unique properties in "preparing" individuals for psychedelic or mystic experience. For example, the "witness phenomena" (seen in creativity in section 4.37m) is also seen in Integral Yoga (section 4.68). Psychological and semantic flexibility (sections 4.371), and general systems theory, (section 4.38) are akin to synergy and other similar effects seen in Integral Yoga (section 4.68). There is also relation between serendipity (section 4.37d) and some similar effects found in both Transcendental Meditation and Biofeedback. Creativity, hence, like Biofeedback and Meditation, prepares its practitioners in some sense for the "Response Experience" (Jhana-1), and the "Access State" (Jhana- 0) which had earlier been thought to be the function of meditation alone. Indeed, it appears that all of the procedures of the creative level, besides their outer benefits, have in common to a greater or less degree this preparatory function for the glories of the psychedelic state.

5. One of the remarkable aspects of meditation is the absolute unanimity with which all systems, Christian, Hindu, and others name it as an indispensable component of development and deliverance. Even the name is the same everywhere (see Table XII). Meditation, said St. Teresa, (Leuba, 1925:163) is the upper limit of the range of mental activity. In this statement she indicates an intuitive realization of the difference between procedures and graces, for this is as far as man can go by his own effort. She also appears to recognize that at this level distractions are annoying. St. Francois de Sales (Leuba, 1925:167-8) says much the same, pointing that meditation often takes place with difficulty owing to distractions. Christian meditations appear to differ from mantric meditations in that thoughts of love of God are uppermost in the former, while cessation of all thought is sought in the latter. Poulain (1912:7-12, Leuba, 1925:177) adds to meditation (discursive prayer), affective prayer (in which the affections are predominant), and The Prayer of Simplicity or The Prayer of Simple Regard (quiet adoration). In yogic meditation (Eliade, 1969:84-88) having disposed of the lower form with its distractions, the yogi passes to a higher form without distraction which would fall into jhana-1, and hence into the Psychedelic Stage (section 4.71). Meditation then, appears universally recognized as the last conscious procedure instituted from man alone, involving some kind of cognitive reflection, subject to annoying distractions, but an indispensable prologue to Psychedelic Ecstasy.

Wilhelm (1962:50-1) describes three confirmatory evidences of progress towards enlightenment in meditation:

(page 351)

a. the sound of men talking at a distance, like a muffled echo,
b. light in the eyes so that everything before one becomes bright,
c. levitation, a feeling of being drawn upward.
6. The creative stage is characterized by five procedures, tantric sex, creativity, orthocognition, biofeedback, and meditation. From first to last, the procedures steadily become more cerebral, more unselfish, more concerned with mind-expansion, and more involved in control of the environment. This stage is truly the arena of activity of any adult who has escalated from the formal operations level of Piaget. The whole stage with its five procedures is therefore of intense interest to the intelligent, educated adult. It forms an indispensable bridge to growth and self-actualization for our culture, and constitutes the only method of making ready for, or understanding the phenomena of, the psychedelic stage. It is for this reason that we have taken the space to discuss it so specifically.

The procedures in general, across the three modes from prototaxic to syntaxic, appear to be specific and distinct methods of contacting the numinous element, generally in an altered state of consciousness (although this fact is less true with the higher procedures than it is with the lower). From sometimes gross and somatic aspects, the procedures become more cognitive and cerebral; they gain in social effect and benefit; they steadily become more developmental. They end with meditation which is suitably an invitation for something higher - namely a grace.
 
 

4.7 PSYCHEDELIA AND ECSTASY

We now come to the psychedelic stage with its six levels of graces and with the most remarkable, emergent, and spectacular properties. The most egregious of these is mystic ecstasy, found uniformly throughout the stage, and the principle characteristic which distinguishes a grace from a procedure - namely that the procedure can be initiated, but the grace comes from without or "on high." Every culture has its traditions of mysticism; we prefer the word psychedelia, as pointing to the mind-expansion involved in the process. Consciousness indeed wakes up in a corner of space and time, and in a little ego, yet its potential is to become conscious of all space, all time, and of transpersonality.

(page 352-353)

Table XII Comparison of Mystic and Psychedelic Levels in Christian and Hindu Sources

(page 354)

As we did in the last procedure of meditation, we shall perforce lean heavily on Hindu sources, not only because they are clearer, but also because they are more amenable to psychological investigation than are Christian. Nevertheless, we shall in deference to the background of most of our readers quote as many Christian sources as are appropriate. This will lead to some seeming dichotomy, since the two religious traditions are not completely compatible. Riviere (1973:69-70) points out a doctrinal difference between Eastern and Western forms of mysticism. Whereas in the West, mysticism is looked upon as a grace from on high, for which man cannot prepare a sufficient but only a necessary condition, in the yoga tradition, this development is seen as a natural accretion of powers which depend upon the disciple's own efforts.

Webster's 1971 addendum defines psychedelic (from psyche-soul, and delos-reveal) (for its first meaning) as follows: "Relating to or causing an exposure of normally repressed psychic elements." We shall use this meaning, rather than employing "psychedelia" as a synonym for drug use. Watts (1972:354) uses "psychedelic" to mean 'mind manifesting'.

Natural psychedelic experiences occur in a wide number of differing situations, involving certain common elements:

1) The attention of the subject is gripped, and his perception narrowed or focused on a single event or sensation;
2) which appears to be an experience of surpassing beauty or worth;
3) in which values or relationships never before realized are instantaneously or very suddenly emphasized;
4) resulting in the sudden emergence of great joy and an orgiastic experience of ecstasy;
5) in which individual barriers separating the self from others or nature are broken down;
6) resulting in a release of love, confidence, or power; and
7) some kind of change in the subsequent personality, behavior, or artistic product after the rapture is over.


"Psychedelic experience" means a mind-expanding or mind-disclosing experience, and is not confined to the narrow use in terms of psychoactive drugs. It embraces mystic, peak, ecstatic, oceanic, illuminative, nature, communal, and other types of experiences having certain common qualities revealing emergent aspects of mind, and contact or union, immediate and not through the senses, with some absolute (see Gowan 1974: ch 3).

Assuredly there are gradations in these experiences; they are not all of equal depth. There are several aspects which appear to be common to them all:

1) they often have an uncanny, supernormal quality;
2) they involve euphoria or bliss to an extent unknown in most usual activities;
3) they seem to be important in some strange way;
4) there is some element of transcendence, and
5) they remain in the memory longer and more vividly than ordinary events.
Maslow (Mooney and Razik, 1967, p. 49ff) describes some of the characteristics of persons having peak experiences. He lists them as

(page  355)

"giving up the past, giving up the future, innocence, a narrowing of consciousness, loss of self-consciousness, disappearance of fear, lessening of defenses, strength and courage, acceptance, trust, receptivity, integration, ability to dip into the preconscious, aesthetic perceiving, spontaneity, expressiveness, and fusion with the world."

Stace (1960) identifies nine qualities of the psychedelic experience as follows:

1) unity,
2) transformation of space and time,
3) deeply felt positive mood,
4) sacredness,
5) objectivity and reality,
6) paradoxicality,
7) alleged ineffability,
8) transiency, and
9) persisting positive changes in subsequent behavior.


Russell (1925:9) describes the credo of the mystic which is essentially what has been said in sections 4.1 and 4.5 as:

1) there is a better way of gaining information than through the senses;
2) there is unity in all things,
3) there is no reality in time, and
4) all evil is mere appearance.


Masters and Houston (1966:266) report:
The Integral Level. When we examine those psychedelic experiences which seem to be authentically religious, we find that during the session the subject has been able to reach the deep integral level wherein lies the possibility of confrontation with a Presence variously described as God, Spirit, Ground of Being, Mysterium, Noumenon, Essence, and Ultimate or Fundamental Reality. In this confrontation there no longer is any question of surrogate sacrality. The experience is one of direct and unmediated encounter with the source level of reality, felt as Holy, Awful, Ultimate, and Ineffable.

Bucke (1923) was the first writer to give a semi-psychological explanation to the psychedelic state. His book Cosmic Consciousness, although heavily loaded with the religious usage of the time, recorded what he called the "illumination" of 45 individuals, and thus provided a prototype for Maslow's later study on self-actualized persons. He was the first to bring mysticism into the light of psychological examination. He defined his "illumination" as follows:
 

a) The person, without warning, has a sense of being immersed in a flame or cloud;
b) he is bathed in an emotion of joy, assurance, triumph, or salvation;
c) an intellectual illumination, a clear conception or vision of the meaning of the universe; he sees and knows that the Cosmos is a living presence;
d) a sense of immortality;
e) the vanishing of the fear of death;
f) and sin;
g) the whole experience is instantaneous or nearly so,
Page 356)
h) the previous character of the percipient is important,
i) so is the age at which the experience occurs (which is between 25 and 40),
j) there is added a charm of personality,
k) and in some case change in appearance such as might happen to one who experienced great joy.
Viewed psychologically the adventitious elevation of an individual into a higher state of consciousness, such as a nature mystic experience must be viewed with considerable interest. There has obviously been an excess of pranic energy, but why has it taken the outlet of bringing a higher state of experience into consciousness? One can only speculate that there must be some predisposing cause (high intelligence, poetic, artistic, or high moral disposition, etc), and an environmental "trigger" (nature, etc.) which produces a temporary escalation into a higher developmental state, much as an encounter group may produce a peak experience in one ready for it.

The every day processes of living in the conscious mind usually succeed in the average individual in successfully compartmentalizing off the preconscious. But very occasionally, we find, for reasons that we are yet unaware, the upwelling of the preconscious area, like the eruption of molten magma from the mantle of the earth. This onset of active subliminal life may appear as the prepsychotic panic reaction of Boisen (1932) in those for whom its coming is premature and prototaxic. In artists and others of parataxic outlets, it may surface as the sudden shift in life style which overtook Gauguin and transformed him from a French bourgeois to a tropical castaway. Finally, in those already creative or firmed in the syntaxic mode, it appears as a creative or higher opening, poetical, musical, or even as a theophany or mystic ecstasy.

It is even possible that the psychedelic state is somewhat different than that reported by the mystics of the past (i.e., a state of fortuitous graces), and that it embraces a larger domain of which transports, raptures, and ecstasies are merely the affective overload. If mind expansion can occur without the emotional effects usually associated with it in the past, and if the psychedelic stage is now within reach of the "normal" developmental process, then one may reasonably ask: (1) what are the disposing characteristics of readiness, and (2) what is the psychedelic state without the appearance of the conventional psychic powers?

The disposing characteristics of readiness seem to be clearly outlined in the "prayer of quiet" aspects of the higher meditative state in which distractions do not occur. The psychedelic state without conventional psychic manifestations consists in increased control over one's

(page 357)

mind, one's feelings, and one's environment, so that one ceases to be a reactive being and begins (as part of the noumenon) to design one's life and future. But before going further, it is necessary to point out emphatically that it is possible to be in the psychedelic state and not have peak experiences or ecstasies. Though Bucke included Emerson "out" of his illumined elect because Emerson was too cognitive for such an experience, Maslow was wise enough to realize that there are "peakers" and "non-peakers." (The writer admits that he is one of the latter). While non-peakers might become peakers by the infusion of psychoactive drugs, it is possible to learn from vicarious as well as direct experience. The austere attitude of Sri Aurobindo on this subject of ecstasy should caution us adequately (section 4.68). For those still unconvinced, there is a little classic called The Appeal of Quakerism to the Non-Mystic (Littleboy:1916, 1964) which is very helpful. While it is certainly conducive to a good marriage for the wife to go into orgiastic ecstasy twice a week, it is not necessary; the same situation applies here.

From our individual conscious view, a psychedelic experience is an episode when the doors of the preconscious swing open and the conscious mind finds itself master in a new and enlarged domain, with awe and exaltation resulting from new insights and expanded control. From the preconscious side, the phenomenon can be viewed as a final breaking through into consciousness of psychic tension which needed the fresh air of expression. It is at last a full syntaxic consciousness of the numinous, which is finally received at the full cognitive level; it is finally housed in cognitive consciousness, which is its predestined domicile. The juncture involves both expansion of cognitive knowledge and emergent aspects of affective union, seen in the appropriate ecstasy.

All higher religions attempt to clarify this relationship of the individual ego to the general mind. Indeed, the process of life may be viewed as development of the self from ego-centricity to a merging with the noumenon in psychedelic experience. Cogitation (literally a "shaking-up") explains the discontinuity of successive developmental stages in which the ego is reoriented by permuting its relationship, first to the world of experience, then to itself, then to the beloved other (see Gowan 1974:48ff). This cycle of differential emphasis forces the ego into new experiences, breaking it loose from ego-centricity, and directing it on a sequence culminating in the full ability to understand its nature and function. Such development eventuates in cognitive access to the preconscious, which allows conscious juncture with the numinous, and the prerogatives and powers of the psychedelic state.

(page 358)

4.71 Response Experiences37

The initial grace in the psychedelic stage is the response experience. In response experiences one feels a sense of Presence, but hears not and sees not the Lord; in the Adamic Ecstasy one hears the Lord, but does not see him. In the Knowledge Ecstasy, one sees the Lord. In Knowledge-contact Ecstasy of degree one, one touches Him (or is touched); in Knowledge-contact Ecstasy of degree two, one penetrates Him (or is penetrated by Him). In Knowledge-contact Ecstasy of degree three, one merges with Him.

The name "Response Experience" comes from Laski (1962:100) who denies that it is a true ecstasy (though many others would dispute her), and calls it a response experience because it appears to be "triggered" by some aspect of nature. Perhaps for this reason it is often called a nature-mystic experience, and as such is frequently noted by poets, artists, writers, and other intellectuals. It is also cognate with Freud's "oceanic" experience and Maslow's "peak-experience."

As the "lowest" psychedelic experience, it contains all the basic properties of the class: the self is purified; fear and shame vanish; there is a realization or feeling that "All is one;" the concept of Gemeinschaftsgefuhl or reconciliation with all men as brothers and indeed all life is felt. Christian Scripture tells us that we must be reconciled with our brother and become purified before we can enter the presence of God, and while the preliminary conditions are met, this procedure is "low" precisely because the self does not yet identify the presence it feels as numinous. In place of merging with the numinous element, there is often merging with nature or some natural object, but all experiences of this level involve a oneness with the creation rather than with the creator.

Rufus Jones tells us of his mystical experience which occurred as a young man in the foothills of the Alps (1932:196-7):
 

I was walking alone in the forest, trying to map out my plan of life. . . . Suddenly I felt the walls between the visible and the invisible grow thin, and the Eternal seemed to break through into the world where I was. I saw no flood or light, I heard no voice. But I felt as though I was face to face with a higher order of reality.


Laski (1962:418) quotes Richard Church, the writer, as follows:
 

I felt the hair of my head tingling, and a curtain of red blood appeared to fall before my eyes. I leaned forward, clasping myself close, while the world rocked around me. And as this earthquake
(page 359)
subsided, I saw a new skyline defined. It was a landscape in which objects and words were fused. . . .
Thomas Merton, the mystic friar, describes his theophany (1962:278-9):
 
But what a thing it was, this awareness: it was so intangible, and yet it struck me like a thunderclap. It was a light so bright that it had no relation to any visible light.... It was as if I had suddenly been illuminated by being blinded by the manifestation of God's presence.
Otto (1928:221) quotes George Allen on a numinous experience of the critic John Ruskin:
 
'Lastly, although there was no definite religious sentiment mingled with it, there was a continual perception of Sanctity in the whole of nature, from the slightest thing to the vastest; an instinctive awe, mixed with delight; an indefinable thrill, such as we sometimes imagine to indicate the presence of a disembodied spirit. I could only feel this perfectly when I was alone; and then it would often make me shiver from head to foot with the joy and fear of it, when after being some time away from hills I first got to the shore of a mountain river, where the brown water circled among the pebbles, or when I first saw the swell of distant land against the sunset, or the first low broken wall, covered with mountain moss. I cannot in the least describe the feeling; but I do not think this is my fault, nor that of the English language, for I am afraid no feeling is describable. If we had to explain even the sense of bodily hunger to a person who had never felt it, we should be hard put to it for words; and the joy in nature seemed to me to come of a sort of heart-hunger, satisfied with the presence of a Great and Holy Spirit.'


Underhill (1960:234) regards this initial experience as one held in common by poets, artists, and mystics:
 

To see God in nature, to attain to a radiant consciousness of the "otherness" of natural things, is the simplest and commonest form of illumination. . . Where such a consciousness is recurrent, as it is with many poets, for instance, Keats, Shelley, Wordsworth, Browning, Tennyson, and Whitman, there results a partial yet often overpowering apprehension of the Infinite Life imminent in all living things, which some modern writers have dignified by the name of "nature-mysticism."
(page 360)

Underhill goes on to aver that the true mystic takes this experience as a point of departure, and grows in grace from it, whereas the poet and artist simply use the recurrent experience as a basis for artistic production and personal euphoria.

Since we have elsewhere described many examples of this experience (Gowan 1974:113-119), we forbear further here. Other examples will be found in Bucke (1902), Laski (1962) and Happold (1970:129-142).

This naturally induced psychedelic experience differs from the drug-induced psychedelic experience because the ego is more openly and overtly in control. Some "good trips" on drugs may result in affective elevation similar to the natural psychedelic experience, but "bad trips" on drugs seem to have no counterpart in the natural state, probably because natural psychedelia does not occur until one is ready for it.

Response experiences are much like siddhis, -psychedelic displays, which need to be followed up by action and development. They represent readiness and potentiality, not accomplishment, (see Huxley 1945:68, 171).

Indeed one may look at such response experiences as virtually an example of an ecstasy in the parataxic mode, where the numinous element is veiled by nature, and while one is conscious of a presence, one is not sure what that presence is. Such experiences appear to be triggered both by the good health of the individual and by some natural incident. They are evidence of the wonders that lie ahead, and constitute an earnest and an invitation to proceed. Since the affective precedes the cognitive, there is more affective thrill than cognitive understanding to them. One feels rather than knows. Nevertheless, such experiences can redirect one's life, for they give one the exaltation of standing on a high mountain and gaining for a minute the glory of a grand vista.

In concentrating our attention on ecstasy as the most spectacular aspect of jhana -1, we have not given much attention to the mechanics of progress through the grace. There are both Christian and Hindu traditions about these matters, to which we now turn (Table X11). St. Teresa (Leuba, 1925:164) calls this state the Orison of Quiet; (it is also the fourth dwelling in her Interior Castle). As a "foretaste of supernatural favors," God's grace elevates the soul so that memory and understanding act only spasmodically, and the mind is passive and stilled. Meditation may sometimes be an effort: The Prayer of Quiet is enjoyed for itself. St. Francois de Sales (Leuba, 1925:168) calls this level Contemplation. Thought is immobilized onto simple regard for the loved Deity; there is total attention to this Object. Poulain (1912:13, 65) (Leuba, 1925:178) calls this state The Prayer

(page 361)

of Quiet in which the devotee has crossed "an abyss" (from a procedure to a grace). Poulain explains this change in that while in meditation we may think of the presence of God, in The Prayer of Quiet we feel the presence; (note how well this statement qualifies the state for jhana -1 with its sense of presence.).

Patanjali (Eliade, 1969:88ff) says the same thing more abstractly when he points out that while meditation with distraction "thinks about an object," meditation without distraction brings one to dharma in which one penetrates to the essence of the object, and therefore assimilates it in an almost magical sense. Since the "object" is usually Vishnu (or a similar god), "assimilation" means the presence of the deity.

4.72 Adamic or 'Time Ecstasies ("Access" or Jhana 0)

The next level of ecstasy is one to which Blake's great words "the doors of perception are cleansed" apply. All things are seen in the pristine goodness which Adam found before he fell from grace (hence the name). This is the Hindu "access" state in which the primary object does not fully occupy the mind, but comes and goes transiently. God is heard although not seen. The self is restored to primitive grace. Siddhis are most likely in this stage, particularly those of bodily lightness as though floating on air. There may also be light flashes, or waves before the eyes; also noise like running water or the muffled sound of men talking at a distance. Because at this level there is initial loosening of the time aspect of the triple illusion, there often appears to be renewal or restoration of that which has been lost in the past, hence a reestablishment of pristine glory; this can also become a siddhi in which the individual sees the activities of a former time as in a vision. Another common experience is being enveloped in fire or seeing it close by.

Leuba (1925:209) describes an Adamic Ecstasy (Participant is climbing a mountain):
 

When all at once I experienced a sense of being raised above myself; I felt the presence of God. . . . I could barely tell the boys to pass on and not wait for me. I then sat down on a stone, unable to stand any longer, and my eyes overflowed with tears. I thanked God. . . .


Knox (1950:153) quotes George Fox in another Adamic Ecstasy:
 

Now was I come up in spirit through the flaming sword into the paradise of God. All things were new, and all the creation gave another smell unto me than before, beyond what words
(page 362)
can utter. I know nothing but pureness, innocency, and righteousness being renewed up into the image of God by Christ Jesus, so that I was come up into the state of Adam which he was in before he fell.
Bucke (1923:v) tells about his own "illumination"
 
All at once without warning of any kind I found myself wrapped in a flame colored cloud. . . . Directly afterward there came upon me a sense of exultation ... of immense joyousness, accompanied or immediately followed by an intellectual illumination impossible to describe.


Bucke was surprised to find that such unusual experiences were more common than he had expected, and his book Cosmic Consciousness which catalogs a number of similar ecstasies, (first printed in 1901) has gone through many reprintings. Among the many historical figures cited in the book, one of the most telling is that of Blaise Pascal, famous French scientist and mathematician who had an experience which literally changed his life. He wrote about it as follows (Bucke: 1929:274):
 

In the year of Grace, 1654, Monday, 23 November, day of St. Clement, Pope and Martyr. From about half past ten in the evening until about half -past twelve midnight, FIRE. God of Abraham, God of Isaac, God of Jacob, not the philosophers nor of the Wise. Assurance, joy, assurance, feeling, joy, peace ...


An even more famous example occurred to Moses on Mt. Sinai as related in Exodus3:2-5:
 

And the angel of the Lord appeared unto him in a flame of fire, out of the midst of a bush; and he looked, and behold, the bush burned with fire, and the bush was not consumed. And Moses said, I will now turn aside and see this great sight, why the bush is not burnt. And when the Lord saw that he turned aside to see, God called him out of the midst of the bush, and said: Moses, Moses. And he said, here am 1. And He said, draw not nigh hither; put off thy shoes from off thy feet, for the place wherein thou standest is holy ground.
And perhaps the most famous experience of all is given in Acts 9:3-6:
 
And as he journeyed he came near Damascus, and suddenly there shined about him a light from heaven; and he fell to the ground, and heard a voice saying unto him, Saul, Saul, why persecutest thou me?
(page 363)

Adamic ecstasies show loss of worldliness, desire, sin, sorrow. It is significant that Adamic ecstasies also sometime involve the loss of sense of time.Laski (1962:112) quotes Jefferies who had a similar experience of the Roman legions when standing beside a Roman ruin. Laski quotes Toynbee on similar historical visions on site, and notes the abundance of ruins as triggers for such experiences. She quotes Wordsworth (p. 115) who at Stonehenge had a vision of ancient druids at their rites. One might well call these locus experiences. Since they tune in to the numinous aspects of a site in its durative nature, they are the syntaxic correlates of the prototaxic hauntings and apparitions.

Auden (1956:27-8) muses on archetypes and sacred sites as triggers:

"Some sacred beings seem sacred to all imaginations at all times," and "many of us have sacred landscapes which probably all have much in common."


D. H. Lawrence in The Rainbow (1949:204-5) echoes a similar timelessness:
 

Away from time, always outside of time. . Here in the church, "before" and "after" were folded together, all was contained in oneness.
as does T. S. Eliot in "Four Quartets."

Happold (1970:x368-70) quotes Thomas Traherne on the latter's Adamic ecstasy. Since such an ecstasy recovers "le temps perdu" it constitutes a vision of the durative topocosm:
 

Certainly Adam in Paradise had not more sweet and curious apprehension of the world than I.... All appeared new and strange at first, inexpressibly rare and delightful. . . . All things were spotless, and pure, and glorious. I saw all in the peace of Eden. . . . All time was eternity. . . The corn was orient and immortal wheat, which never should be reaped, nor was ever sown. I thought it had stood from everlasting to everlasting. . . . The men, 0 what venerable and reverend creatures... and the young men glittering and sparkling angels, and maids strange seraphic pieces of life and beauty. ... Boys and girls were moving jewels. I knew not that they were born or should die; but all things abided eternally as they were in their proper places. Eternity was manifest in the light of day, and something infinite behind everything appeared. . . .


The difference between "hearing the Lord" and "seeing the Lord" which distinguishes Adamic ecstasies from Knowledge ecstasies, is illustrated in Exodus 33:9, 11, 18-23.

(page 364)

And it came to pass as Moses entered the tabernacle the cloudy pillar descended and stood at the door of the tabernacle, and the Lord talked with Moses. And the Lord spake unto Moses face to face. . . . And he said "I beseech thee, show me thy glory." And (the Lord) said "Thou canst not see my face; for there shall no man see me and live.... And it shall come to pass that while my glory passeth by, that I will put thee in a cleft in the rock, and will cover thee with my hand, while I pass by. And I will take away my hand and thou shall see my back parts; but my face shall not be seen.
From which it is evident that Moses had an Adamic vision.

Many saints are reputed to have had time ecstasies in which they had a vision of holy events. St. Bridget, while adoring a creche, had a vision of Jesus' birth. St. Francis received the Stigmata in a similar instance. St. Teresa, and many others have had such theophanies.

Let us see what the mystics say about jhana 0, or the "access" state. St. Teresa (Leuba, 1912:164) calls this "The Sleep of the Powers" or the Orison of Union (in her Interior Castle where it is the fifth dwelling). As the last state before complete rapture, the soul is more and more absorbed in the complete contemplation of God, which is found more and more enjoyable. The intellectual and sensory powers seem asleep. Teresa calls this state "a celestial madness." Similar strong affective aspects are mentioned by St. Francois de Sales (Leuba, 1912:168) who calls it Amorous Abstraction and mentions the "presence of the Bridegroom;" "the soul hears his voice." Mental activity is reduced to nil. Father Poulain (1912) Leuba (1925:178) calls this state Full Union. He says:
 

The soul is fully occupied with the divine object; it is not diverted by any other thought; in short it has no distractions.
The Hindus also agree that this level involves ecstasy which they call "samadhi." The lowest level is samadhi "with support" (sampajnata) in which samadhi is achieved (Eliade, 1969:93) "with the help of an object or a thought." The yogi penetrates the essence of the object, and assimilates it, but he is still differentiated from it. This samadhi level makes possible knowledge and puts an end to suffering. While there is not perfect correspondence between the yogic graces and the Christian, either here or in the next samadhi level, there is an outside-of-time aspect which corresponds to our Adamic Ecstasy. For example, in "gripping" an object the yogi assimilates its past and future, as well as its present.

(page  365)

The analysis of Adamic time Ecstasies can offer comfort to those persons disturbed by the doom-saying of mystics like Edgar Cayce. Let us remember that under the conditions of the vision (which appears in pictorial form and must later be interpreted in words), the time element has become "distorted," that is, we are in the domain of the "durative topocosm" not clock time. What the mystic therefore interprets as a vision of the future may in actuality be an Adamic Ecstasy recovering the past. A good example of this is the experience of George Fox, the founder of the Quakers, in Lichfield (Nickalls, 1952:1962:41-2). Fox admits that he confused a paranormal recollection of early Christian persecution in times past with what he interpreted to be a prediction of future events in his famous "Woe unto the bloody city of Lichfield." (ef pp. 49, 141, 165).

It is also important to realize that Christian mystics may have unintentionally deceived us about the actual value of ecstasies themselves. Satprem (1968:194-5) points out that what we call "transcendent" may merely be the limit of our present consciousness, and today's transcendence may be tomorrow's commonplace. Satprem feels that the neophyte is wrong "in believing that his ecstasy is a sign of progress," for instead, it is a sign of inconscience. "Try to develop your inner individuality, and you will be able to enter these regions in full consciousness," and as Sri Aurobindo says: "It is only when the realization is constant in the waking state that it is truly possessed." In a footnote, noting that "extare" by definition means to be outside one's body, Satprem coins a better Latin derivation "enstasy" which is defined as above.

The mystic experiences of various religious leaders are noted by the Thomases (1942:31, 109, 223) who say:
 

Zoroaster on Mt. Sabalon saw the seven faces of Ahura Mazda, who ushered him into heaven and gave him much knowledge. (Jhana 1)

Muhammad on the mountain had a vision and heard the voice of Allah. (Jhana 0)


Swedenborg was prepared for his theophany and the gift of second sight by "three years of abnormally long periods of supernatural slumber filled with a continual and logical sequence of dreams." Swedenborg says of this situation: "I was elevated into heaven by degrees and in proportion as I was elevated, my understanding became enlarged, so that I was gradually enabled to perceive things which at first I had not perceived." This sounds very much like the development of a latent factor of intellect. Swedenborg also prefigures the concept of the hologram in that he believed that everything from the least onwards is in itself an image of the total being. Or as

(page 366)

Emerson puts it: "Nature exists entire in its leasts." Tennyson had the same inspiration:

 
Flower in the crannied wall
I pluck you out of the crannies;
I hold you here, root and all, in my hand,
Little flower- but if I could understand
What you are, root and all, and all in all,
I should know what God and man is.


St. Thomas Aquinas, after a long career as scholar and philosopher to the Catholic Church, had a visionary experience in chapel one Sunday. Declaring that his previous knowledge was as nothing compared with what had been revealed to him, he stopped in the middle of a book, and never wrote another word.

4.73 Knowledge Ecstasy (Jhana 1)34

Knowledge Ecstasies are so called because some transcendent knowledge is communicated suddenly and completely, so that the mystic "knows everything." This cognitive escalation is accompanied by moral illumination of the self. Commonly there is a vision of God who is now seen as well as heard. Hindering thoughts cease, and the primary object is attended constantly without distraction, and with bliss and rapture. As time began to disappear in the previous level, space begins to disappear in this one. This state has a quality of the ineffable, and it is also "noetic" (disclosing depths of knowledge), two characterizations of the mystic state. It is also, of course, transient, and there is passivity of the will.

Allen (1946:30-1) describes an ecstatic experience which occurred to him during a performance of Beethoven's Seventh Symphony:
 

It fell into three parts: first the mysterious event itself which occurred in the infinitesimal fraction of a split second; this I learned afterwards to call the Union . . . then illumination, a wordless stream of complex feelings ... lastly enlightenment, the recollection ... of the whole complex ... embalmed in thought-forms and words.


Reinhold (1973:228) quotes St. Francis of Rome:
 

I saw a very dazzling light that hovered over dense darkness. Within this light there was a tabernacle full of splendor, and above this tabernacle was our Saviour in His sacred human form, and His holy wounds streamed forth rays that garmented the saints with wonderful glory. A great number of saints surrounded
(page 367)
Him. The Queen of Heaven was also there, and on her head she wore her three crowns from which beams of vivid light emanated. Then I saw other souls that were still one with their bodies. They entered this fire and left it again. Now this fire was the symbol of divine love. I was curious to know who these souls were that I beheld pass through the flame. I was told they belonged to living men who perservered in holy love, and that they came to renew holy love in this furnace.


St. Teresa calls jhana 1 Ecstasy or "Rapture of the Flight of the Soul" (Leuba, 1912:165). It is the sixth dwelling in her Interior Castle. In St. Teresa's words, this is virtual trance, which "comes on more suddenly than the other states, and can with much less success be resisted." When she tried "astonishing forces ... lifted me up." Thus she experienced levitation, one of the siddhis associated with jhanas 1-3. St. Francois de Sales (Leuba, 1925:168) calls this state The Liquefaction of the Soul in God. Poulain (1912) refers to it simply as ecstasy in which "we are no longer able to come out of our prayer at will."

The Hindus call this state Savitarka Samadhi (argumentative) because (Eliade, 1969:95) thought identifies itself with the object meditated on in its essential totality. This direct perception of objects extends to their past and their future. In this Patanjali identifies this state as a "Knowledge Ecstasy" in which knowledge is communicated (Table XII).
Reinhold quotes St. Hildegard (1973:58):
 

1 saw what seemed to be a great iron-colored mountain. On it sat someone in such glory of light that his radiance dazzled me. On either side a wing both broad and long was spread. Before him stood a shape covered over with eye upon eye. . .


Let us reread Isaiah (6:1-7) which tells of his initial vision:
 

I saw the Lord sitting upon a throne, high and lifted up, and his train filled the temple. Above him stood the seraphim; each one had six wings; with twain he covered his face; with twain he covered his feet; with twain he did fly. And one cried unto another "Holy, holy, holy is the Lord of Hosts. The fullness of the whole earth is his glory" . . . And the posts of the door were moved at the voice of them that called and the house was filled with smoke. Then said 1: "Woe is me, for I am undone; Because I am a man of unclean lips; for mine eyes have seen the King, the Lord of Hosts." Then flew unto me one of the seraphim, with a glowing stone in his hand, which he had taken with the
(page 368)
tongs from off the altar; and he touched my mouth with it, and said: "Lo this hath touched thy lips; and thy iniquity is taken away and thy sin expiated."
And again, St. Rose' vision of heaven:
 
I was suspended in quiet contemplation like a light uniting all things, when I saw a flash of wonderful splendor. In the center of the radiance was a rainbow of lucent reflections and colors and over it another of equal grandeur . . . . Above the arches stood the cross ... and within the arches ... shone the form of my Lord. . . .


As Underhill (1960:359) notes, ecstasy is a form of higher trance, "more or less deep, and more or less prolonged." During the trance there is the usual depression in breathing and circulation, with anesthesia and siddhis. (Underhill notes that Bernadette "held a flaming candle in her hand for fifteen minutes during one of her ecstasies. She felt no pain, either did the flesh show any marks of burning.") Rapture, as Underhill (1930:375) notes, is "a sudden and irresistible seizure of ecstasy." As St. Teresa describes it: "In a trance the soul dies gradually to outward things ... rapture comes as a shock, quick and sharp ... you feel and see yourself carried away." Rapture, thus looms very much like a conscious OOB experience (or if you prefer, levitation). Says St. Teresa: "At least I was so much myself as to be able to see that I was being lifted up." Underhill (1930:377) notes that Rulman Merswin was carried around the garden in his rapture, as was St. Catherine of Siena.
St. Catherine of Siena writes:

Oftentimes through the perfect union which the soul has made with Me, she is raised up from the earth almost as if the heavy body became light.

Poulain (1912:278-9) quotes St. Ignatius Loyola speaking of himself in the third person:
 

... sitting on the banks.... his mind was suddenly filled with a new and strange illumination, so that in one moment, and without any sensible image or appearance, certain things ... were revealed ... and this so abundantly ... that if all ... which he had received up to the time he was more than sixty-two years old could be collected into one ... all this knowledge would not equal what was at that moment conveyed
(page 369)

Jacob Boehme, the German cobbler, tells of his experience (Bucke: 1929:182):
 

The gate was opened to me that in one-quarter of an hour, I saw and knew more than if I had been many years together at a university, and which I exceedingly admired and thereupon turned my praise to God for it. For I saw and knew the being of all things, the byss and the abyss ...

(page 369)


4.74 Knowledge-Contact Ecstasy of Degree 1 (Jhana 2)

We now come to the first of three levels of knowledge-contact which are characterized by increasing degrees of the mystic being touched by (or touching) the numinous object. (The Christian way of stating this is that "God wounds the soul"). At the first level the primary object is transcended, and the self is embodied spiritually. This is the first action of the release of the individual from the prison of selfhood into merging with ultimate reality. Consequently in Knowledge-contact Ecstasy, the self is often felt lost. It is thought, however, that at this first level ecstasy and bliss continue.

Richard Rolle, the English mystic-poet (Wolters 1972:45) says: "My God, my Love, surge over me, pierce me by your love, wound me..."   but later admits: "Yet you will not show yourself to me; you look away. . ." The first statement is a desire for jhana 2; the second is admission of being at the access level. Reinhold 1973:322 quotes St Teresa:
 

Our Lord was pleased that I should have at times a vision of this kind: I saw an angel close by me, on my left side, in bodily form. This I am not accustomed to see unless very rarely. Though I have visions of angels frequently, yet I see them only by an intellectual vision such as I have spoken of before. It was our Lord's will that in this vision I should see the angel in this wise. He was not large, but small of stature and most beautiful, his face burning as if he were one of the highest angels, who seem to be all of fire: they must be those whom we call cherubim. Their names they never tell me; but I see very well that there is in heaven so great a difference between one angel and another, and between those and the others, that I cannot explain it.

I saw in his hand a long spear of gold, and at the iron's point there seemed to be a little fire. He appeared to me to be thrusting it time and again into my heart, and to pierce my very entrails; when he drew it out, he seemed to draw them out also, and to leave me all on fire with a great love of God. The pain was so great that it made me moan; and yet so surpassing was the

(page 370)
sweetness of this excessive pain that I could not wish to be rid of it. The soul is satisfied now with nothing less than God.


Wayman (Prince 1968:168) discusses three mystic stages of increasing primitiveness (or retreat from our normal discursive consciousness) Analogous to the prototaxic, parataxic, and syntaxic modes he reports that yogins reach a non-discursive ecstasy from "sound, form, or the tangible." "It would be the difference between hearing the Lord (commonest), seeing the Lord (much rarer), and touching the Lord (rarest of all)."

Younghusband (1935:162) describes the passion of St. Therese of Lisieux:
 

I was in the choir ... when suddenly I felt myself wounded by a dart of fire so ardent, I thought I should die ... But what fire - what sweetness. Flames of love.


Underhill (1960:379) puts it well:

In the third degree of ardent Love, says Richard of St. Victor, love paralyzes action. Union (copula) is the symbol of this state; ecstasy is its expression. The desirous soul, he says finely, no longer thirsts for God but into God.

Speaking of the Indian mystic Ramakrishna, Younghusband (1930:27) says:
 

It was impossible to express in language the ecstasy of divine communication when the human soul lost itself in contemplation of the Deity.
Underhill (1960:356-7) quotes St. Teresa on the Contact Union Ecstasy:
 
In this state there is no sense of anything; only fruition, without understanding what that may be the fruition of which is granted. ... This state lasts only a short time, though the faculties do not . . . recover . . . for some hours. . . . It cannot be more clearly described, because what then takes place is so obscure. All I am able to say is that the soul is represented as being close to God ... All the faculties fail now, and are suspended. In the prayer of union the soul is asleep ... as regards herself and earthly things. The soul neither sees, hears, nor understands anything while in this state . . .
Laski (1961:123) says:
 
Sometimes the contact is felt to pass information, and we have
(page 371)
a knowledge contact ecstasy, sometimes the contact is closer, and no information is passed, and sometimes this contact is of union.


The best Christian explication of the distinction between these three degrees of Knowledge-contact Ecstasies (Jhanas 2, 3, 4) was made by St. John of the Cross whom Reinhold (1973:329ff) quotes as follows:
 

Love unites the soul with God, and the more degrees of love the soul has, the more profoundly does it enter into God and the more is it centered in Him; and thus we can say that, as are the degrees of love of God, so are the centeres, each one deeper than another, which the soul has in God; these are the many mansions which, He said, were in His Father's house. And thus the soul which has one degree of love is already in its center in God, since one degree of love suffices for a soul to abide in Him through grace. If it have two degrees of love, it will have entered into another and a more interior center with God; and, if it attain to three, it will have entered into the third. If it attain to the last degree, the love of God will succeed in wounding the soul even in its deepest center - that is, in transforming and enlightening it as regards all the being and power and virtue of the soul, such as it is capable of receiving, until it be brought into such a state it appears to be God.


Outside of St. John of the Cross, there are no clear Christian distinctions here between jhanas 2, 3, and 4. They are essential Knowledge-contact Ecstasies of greater and greater degrees of intimacy and absorption. The Hindus do a better job. Patanjali (Eiade, 1969:9699) describes these as "knowledge states" with "miraculous powers." In jhana 2, Nirvitarka Samadhi (non-argumentative), the memory and logical operations of the mind have halted, and "thought is delivered from the presence of the ego." We would say that the object is transcended. In jhana 3, rapture ceases and there is direct knowledge. In jhana 4, all feelings cease, space and time are transcended, and there is "a fusion of all modalities of being." As creation is differentiation, so yogic escalation is integration, in which things go back into their original undifferentiated order.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Let us imagine that a rather naive psychologist proposed to study happiness in marriage, and having no personal experience with that state himself, but having read that sex is important in marriage, and that orgasm is important in sex, he decides to rate the happiness of various marriages on the rate of orgasm experienced. Would his

(page 372)

study be a very valid one? If we fall into a similar trap in allowing ourselves to "rate" syntaxic numinous experience in terms of ecstasy we have only our naivete to blame. For just as there are many aspects of marriage other than orgasm which contribute to conjugal happiness, there are many aspects of cognitive syntaxic development which are independent of the affective overtones of ecstasy and rapture.

It is even possible that we have been emotionally seduced by the "orgasm" concept of ecstasy; since orgasm is good, mystic ecstasy must be better. But as Sri Aurobindo austerely points out (Satprem, 1968:194-5)it is possible that ecstasy is merely the overloading of the affective channel:
 

Then instead of fainting away at the summit or what he takes for the summit, and believing that his ecstasy is a sign of progress, the seeker must understand that is is a sign of inconscience, and work to discover the living existence under his bedazzlement. Try to develop your inner individuality, says the Mother, and you will be able to enter these very regions in full consciousness. ... (i.d.)


This very reasonable view looks at ecstasy as a boundary of our present abilities, not as a definite state, and it explains both the somewhat disturbing fact that mystic trance looks a bit like prototaxic trance, and the ecstatic experiences grow less and not more as one comes nearer the unitive state. If this be true, and Sri Aurobindo prove a better guide to these regions than St. Teresa, the whole literature of mysticism needs to change its focus. Indeed, the word "ecstasy" from the Latin exstare (to be outside oneself) would need to be changed to "enstasy" (from enstare, to be inside oneself).

We shall continue with the "Christian" concept of ecstasy in our development of the graces, but this saving comment should alert us to the fact that this entire tradition may be founded on a misconception induced by affective overload.

Professor Leuba (1925) is skeptical about mystic ecstasy being more than hypnotic trance, self-imposed. He notes (Ibid: 187)that "the very first trance-experiences reach an intensity of feeling ... never to be surpassed" in which it resembles the "venting" of glossolalia (section 2.51) rather than any developmental effect. He also notes that the feeling of certainty of knowledge imparted under ecstasy is often felt under other types of mechanically or hypnotically induced trance where the evaluative faculty of the reason is held in abeyance. Finally he notes the great difference between the active, practical charity of the unitive state, and the automatisms of the psychedelic state. 'The wonders of trance ... had lost much of their initial glamor

(page 373)

and . . . had receded to a subordinate place."

Since we are scientists, not religionists, it is not for us to follow Marechal in attacking Leuba for his skepticism. We would point out however, that Leuba lived in a time when most psychologists (with the exception of James) found it necessary to espouse such views because there was little support for any other. In contrast, the work since Leuba's time on the preconscious, creativity, the numinous element, developmental progress, biofeedback, self-actualization, psychedelia, and many other issues taken up in this volume give modern psychologists a much larger option.

4.75 Knowledge-Contact Ecstasy of Degree 2 (Jhana 3)

At this level all ecstasy and rapture cease. God not only touches the soul; he enters in. The self is made "like fire and light."

Reinhold (1973:361) quotes Symeon the Younger:
 

Again I saw Him in my house. Among all those everyday things He appeared unexpectedly and became unutterably united and merged with me, and leaped over to me without anything in between, as fire to iron, as the light to glass. And He made me like fire and like light. And I became that which I saw before and beheld from afar. I do not know how to relate this miracle to you.


Indeed it is possible that with the entrance of the numinous element "into" the saint, we have passed beyond the syntaxic mode itself, and are in something which can only be called the "meta-syntaxic" mode. Words and knowledge now cease to be very useful as either explanation or communication being succeeded by graces which are essentially ineffable and incommunicable. While we shall continue for the sake of simplicity to regard these higher graces as ostensibly belonging to the syntaxic mode, it should be understood that they involve a limit situation whose properties clearly transcend the attributes of the mode. An immediate corollary of this fact is that from now on we shall find the paradox of opposites ("neither perception nor non-perception") included in a plenum which transcends our understanding but has meaning at its own level. The Hindus call this level Savicara Samadhi in which there is direct knowledge and rapture ceases.

4.76 Knowledge-Contact Ecstasy of Degree 3 (Jhana 4)

This level completes the release of the self, which is transcended. All feelings cease. For the individual merges with the numinous element, and the "perceiver is one with the perceived." Words and

(page 374)

descriptions now begin to fail to express adequately and accurately the transcendent activities, and are no more suitable to the occasion than prototaxic grunts would be in response to a great work of art.

In Underhill's words (1960:367)"The Transcendent is perceived by contact not vision."

"Oh, wonder of wonders," says Eckhart, "when I think of the union the soul has with God." And Suso says: "In this rapture the soul disappears, yet not entirely; it acquires certain qualities of divinity, but does not naturally become divine." Plotinus puts it; "The soul neither sees nor distinguishes by seeing." "It ceases to be itself ... it belongs to God." "The perceiver is one with the thing perceived." "Ecstasy is a desire of contact ... and a striving after union."

Underhill (1960:416)lists the three marks of the state as:
 

1. absorption in the interests of the Infinite,
2. freedom and serenity flowing from consciousness of its authority,
3.a center of energy in the world and lives of others.
Meister Eckhart tells us:
 
The knower and the known are one . . . God and I we are one. . . . The eye with which I see God is the same as that with which He sees me.
Cognitive knowledge (like carnal knowledge) has in its finality become union.

4.77 Conclusion for Psychedelic Stage

We have now witnessed (on paper) what the Battle Hymn of the Republic so beautifully describes as "the Glory of the  Coming of the Lord."  Whether we prefer to view the Lord as a personal God, or the numinous element as impersonal, the glory and ecstasy are clearly there even when diluted by being recounted on the printed page instead of being actually experienced. This dawning of celestial light has occurred in six stages of grace:

1) the "Response Experience" in which the pre-glow is seen in nature transformed,
2) the Adamic or time Ecstasy in which the self is purified and the "doors of perception are cleansed,"
3) the Knowledge Ecstasy in which the psyche is illuminated through the sight of the numinous element and knowledge is infused,
4) the Knowledge-contact Ecstasy of degree one, which contacts the numinous element and the self begins to disappear,
5) the Knowledge-contact Ecstasy of degree two, which effects deeper contact with the numinous element and rapture ceases, finally
6) in the Knowledge-contact Ecstasy of degree three, all feelings cease and the self merges with the numinous element.
To employ the language of tantricism (also used by some Christian mystics) the

(page 375)

six graces portray:

1) the Bridegroom is present,
2) He is heard,
3) He is seen,
4) He is touched,
5) He penetrates,
6) He merges in complete union.


More austerely the Bhagavad Gita says of the mystical state, samadhi:
 

The self-controlled practitioner, while enjoying the various sense objects through the senses which are disciplined and free from likes and dislikes, attains placidity of mind. With the attainment of such placidity of mind, all his sorrows come to an end, and the intellect of such a person of tranquil mind soon withdraws itself from all sides, and becomes firmly established in the supreme reality.


Harding (1973:159) is definite about the advantages of the syntaxic mode of juncture between the conscious ego and the numinous element:
 

But if a man who has had an ecstatic experience succeeds in holding to his conscious standpoint and its values, and also retains the new influx that has come to him from the very depths of the psyche, he will be obliged to endure the conflict that two such widely different components will necessarily create, and will be compelled to seek for a means of reconciling them. This attitude is the only safeguard against falling under the spell of the nonpersonal daemonic powers of the unconscious; it is the modern way of following John's advice to "prove the spirits." If the effort is successful, an inner marriage will be consummated, the split between the personal and the nonpersonal part of the psyche will be healed, and the individual will become a whole, a complete being.


But perhaps the best metaphor is that of coming home. St. Augustine says: "Thou has made us for thyself and we are not happy until we dwell in thee." As Ruysbroeck says: "God is the home of the soul." One might quote Stevenson's epitaph as it so pertinently applies to the psyche:

 
Here he lies where he longed to be;
Home is the sailor, home from the sea;
And the hunter home from the hill.


4.8 THE UNITIVE STAGE

While Christian mysticism pretty well stops with jhana 4, the last procedure of the psychedelic stage, the Hindus tell us of four higher

(page 376)

jhanas which make up what we now call the unitive stage (previously, 1972, it was described as "illumination"). This is the fifth state of consciousness of the yogis, a state in which the altered state of consciousness is permanent. It is also a stage where all aspects of self have been transcended. It is consequently very difficult to say anything about it, as words are not adequate. Paradoxical statements abound as in most limit situations. (Christians who may be offended when such a mystic says "I am become God" may be comforted by recollecting that what the mystic is really trying to describe is an ineffable situation in which the semantic aspect becomes distorted.) What is apparent is that development has reached some higher level where there is even less of space, time, and "I-ness" and even more of the Absolute.

Laski (1962:63) quotes Poulain on the unitive state as:

1) a union that is almost permanent,38 persisting even amid exterior occupations;
2) transformation of the higher abilities (hence transforming union);
3) intellectual vision.
We will make a very brief description of the four higher jhanas, depending mostly on Goleman (1972).

4.81 Ineffable Contact (Jhana 5)

Here there is incommunicable knowledge communicated, and "consciousness of infinite space" (Goleman, 1972).

We need not detain ourselves with vain quibbles about whether the mystic is absorbed into Deity or whether he retains his conscious individuality. Words are simply not relevant or adequate, for paradoxical opposites become possible simultaneously at such exalted levels. What has happened is that the "not-me" of the early numinosium has become the me, and in place of dissociation, incongruity, and discontinuity between the numinous element and the individual psyche, there has come association, congruity, and continuity.

Jung states in the Secret of Golden Flower:

Every statement about the transcendental ought to be avoided because it is a laughable presumption on the part of the human mind, unconscious of its limitations.
4.82 Transcendental Contact (Jhana 6)

Here there is "objectless infinite consciousness" (Goleman 1972)
Younghusband quotes Ramakrishna's report of NirvakalpaSamadhi (1930:76):
 

In that rapture his senses and mind stopped their function. The body became motionless as a corpse. The universe rolled
(page 377)
away from his vision. Even space melted away. Everything was reduced to ideas, which floated like shadows in the dim background of his mind, only the faint consciousness of "I" repeated itself in dull monotony. Presently that too stopped and what remained was transcendence alone. The soul had lost itself in the Self, and all ideas of duality, of subject and object had been effaced. Beyond speech, beyond experience, and beyond thought, he has experienced the Brahman - he has become the Brahman.


4.83 Ineffable Union (Jhana 7)

Here there is "awareness of 'no-thing-ness.'" As Underhill (1960:415) puts it:

 
The metaphysical mystic for whom the Absolute is impersonal and transcendent describes his final attainment of that Absolute as deification or the utter transmutation of the self in God.


While we are unable to describe in detail what is going on at these exalted levels, that does not mean that little is taking place. The real business of these high states is to make increasingly permanent and real the intimations of escape from the prison of time, space, and personality begun in the lower jhanas. For example, the Adamic Ecstasy (Jhana 0) with its time distortion starts the process of escape from time, but this feeling is experienced only in an ephemeral manner as if in trance: it is the first wiggle of the nascent butterfly in attempting to escape from the cocoon. Such transcendence becomes increasingly apparent at each higher level. Similarly the escape from the physical world of space is started at jhana 1, yet it is obvious from the descriptions of jhana 5, 6, and 7, that different aspects of this transcendence are being accomplished. Words may be inadequate to express the process of these high graces, and we may know little about what is going on, but we can intuit that the continued specifics of this transcendence are much involved.

Referring to Table XII, St. Teresa (Leuba, 1925:165) calls this unitive level Spiritual Marriage. Poulain (1912; Leuba, 1925:179) calls it Transforming Union. Patanjali (Eliade, 1969:100) calls the state Asampajnata Samadhi(samadhi without support), in which being and knowledge are undifferentiated, and thus the yogi becomes one with the deity. None of these authorities distinguish the unitive stage as having four jhanas, as does Goleman in Table VIII.

4.84 Transcendental Union (Jhana 8)

Here there is "neither perception nor non-perception" and it is obvious that words have now ceased to be of any use. It is also obvious

(page 378)

that the individual psyche is now free of the triple prison of time, space, and personality, and to all effects appears to have merged with the numinous element, thus completing its journey through time, space, and personality and returning home.

While Goleman (1972) enters into a discussion of these levels, they are so far removed from most of us as to be a subject of only academic interest, even presuming that we can understand what is being said about them. It is probable that process is more important than position at these levels, and that no great good is served by the discussion of matters which we are really not ready for.

At this point it is suggested that Table X  (Successive Integrations) again be inspected, remembering that a psychedelic vision is a psychological method of integration. Can it be that jhanas -1 and 0 (Response Experience and Adamic Ecstasies) are really openings onto the durative topocosm, that jhanas 1 to 4 (Knowledge Ecstasies) are openings to the entity level, and jhanas 5 to 8 involve archetypes? All of these levels would seem numinous to us, and humanity in general may have been very presumptive in the thought that any of the jhanas could reach to the Absolute.

It is important to attempt to restate for our Western minds, which are not used to the concept, that for the Hindu yogi, extreme concentration on an object becomes "grasping the object", first in knowledge of the essence of the object, and then in a "passage from knowledge to state," essentially becoming the object. Since the object is usually Isvara (the Lord), the result of this progression is deliverance. As Eliade 1969:96 explains:
 

The object is no longer known through associations. . . . it is grasped directly, in its existential nakedness. . . .Let us note that. . . . Samprajnata Samadhi is shown to be a "state achieved through a certain knowledge". . . . This passage from knowledge to state must be kept constantly in mind.... (it) leads to a fusion of all modalities of being. . . .
This absolute knowledge reveals that "knowledge and being are no longer discrete from each other."  So the yogi who penetrates to Asamprajnata Samadhi (samadhi without support of objects) becomes one with the Deity. As Eliade 1969:114 remarks:
 
The human consciousness is eliminated ... its constituent functions having been reabsorbed into the primordial substance. . . . He is "the man delivered in life". He no longer lives in time, but in an eternal present, in the nunc stans that was Boetius' definition of eternity.
(page 379)

If creation may be compared to the mathematical process of differentiation, then yogic escalation may be compared to the process of integration, for it returns to an undifferentiated state or function.35

If the thoughtful reader will now re-examine the relationship between subject and object, between noumenon and phenomenon, between the knower and the known, especially in sections 2.3 (Trance), 3.62 (Parataxic Mode: Image-Magic) and the present section in the Syntaxic mode, he will see the central thesis of this volume emerge: namely, that in the juncture between the individual and the general mind, duality is abolished, and through knowledge more and more complete, the one becomes the other.36 Notice that in section 4.2 (Tantric Sex), if the word know is used in the carnal sense, the knower and the known are fused in union. This integration or return to primordial unity is the finality of knowledge which in the end transmutes into being. Thus the dichotomy of symbol and referent, verba and res, thought and action, Shiva and Shakti is resolved by their transcendence of duality in union. "I am become God"; says Meister Eckhart, testifying truthfully to a mystic state which was as far beyond the comprehension of the churchmen who excommunicated him as the fact that complete knowledge can become complete being is above us. The omega point is reached when "the All shall know the All" for then All shall become All without differentiation. At every level, prototaxic, parataxic, and syntaxic, the upward escalation of humanity is a prefiguring of this "divine, far-off event."

But if we in the West have difficulty in grasping such a concept of absolute thought becoming absolute state, we should remember that the very same idea was proclaimed by none other than Socrates in the Symposium when he concluded:
 

This is the life which man should lead above all others in the contemplation of Beauty absolute. . . . Dwelling in that realm alone, he will bring forth not images of beauty, but Beauty itself, and so would become immortal and be the friend of God.


4.9 CONCLUSION

We have now come to the end of our analysis of the various procedures by which contact with the numinous element may be effected. It may be appropriate here to set down a number of observations and conclusions which have accrued during this investigation:

1. It should now be clear that the object of existence is the union of the individual mind with the General Mind. In order to achieve

(page 380)

this we must escape from three illusions as one does in awakening from a dream. The first is the illusion of the reality of the physical world; the second is the illusion of the reality of time, and the third is the illusion of the reality of the separate self. There are three aspects to this quest, as there are three modes or levels of action. The first aspect is the freeing of the mind from the tyranny of percepts; the second is the escape into the eternal now, and the third is the loss of sense of self through the diffusion of the ego in developmental process. Since the three illusions are properties of the normal state of consciousness, liberation comes only through an altered state of consciousness.

2. The level of this liberation may be either prototaxic, parataxic, or syntaxic, through what we have popularly called trance, art, or creativity. At each level one escapes in some measure from the physical world, from time, and from self. The prototaxic vehicle which accomplishes this is trance. As we have seen, it produces spectacular liberation from the ordinary laws of physics, from time, and from selfhood, but at the price of the loss of conscious cognition and memorability, and the outletting of psychic energy at the kinesthetic level instead of at an aesthetic or cognitive one.

This disvaluing of the prototaxic manifestation of the numinous element in people is not that it is evil, but that it fails to meet the full potential of the human being. It is as de Condren suggested some centuries ago "the receiving of the effects of God and his holy communications in a very animal and carnal way."

3. The parataxic solution offers a bridge between prototaxic and syntaxic, containing some elements of both. Its highest outlet is in art where it offers an aesthetic ASC as a temporary freeing of the artist from physics, from time, and from selfhood. It has the advantage that there is feeling and some cognition involved, though at an iconic (image) representation, rather than at full cognition. The artist retains memorability, but is not always privileged to understand fully what he has accomplished. He is the channel rather than the author of the art. Nevertheless, the production of art objects means that the parataxic mode has social value in utility and beauty, in addition to increased individual benefit.

The domain of the numinousium contains an infinity of event-like elements, real in their realm, but only potential in ours (see Table X). From out this multiple infinity a single chain of events is realized in our space-time, by the reifying action of those conscious minds involved with the events. We speak of "event-like elements" in the numinousium rather than "events," for since that field transcends time as we know it (as ever growing later), our concept of an event

(page 381)

as something that occurs in time, and our concept of one prior event causing a subsequent one, are merely the traces of a meta-event-like element which exists in the eternal now, and "which never was" (in our reality), but "is always happening" (in the eternal now). It is like the pattern in a textile made by the skillful weaving of the warp and woof by a master-weaver. All the thread colors are in all parts of the textile, but only those colors selected by the pattern of the weaver show forth on the surface.

4. Whereas prototaxic man is insulated from the numinous element by the necessity to enter an altered state of consciousness (wherein he generally loses consciousness, will, and memorability) in order to contact it, and whereas parataxic man is in a kind of semi-conductor position in which there is a fail-safe precaution built in on the energy discharge so that (at best or worst), he produces only images, - syntaxic man, with his knowledge of ortho-cognition and its derivative power, acquires corresponding responsibility. For his conscious mind is in contact with the numinous element, (or to put it the other way, it has reached the conscious level at last through his mind). Consequently, he has literally become a co-creator, and whatever he thinks, is liable to become an event in our space-time. With this awesome power goes the responsibility to purify his desires to the extended aspects of his environmental self, and to wish for nothing except that which is good and beneficial to others and to mankind.

5. We should become more aware of the curious symbiotic relationship between the ego and perceptual intake. The conscious ego appears to owe its stability to a narrow range of perceptual inflow; while the environment appears to owe its stability to continued cognizance by the totality of conscious egos. If perceptual intake is restricted, or expanded beyond certain limits, the normal state of consciousness as we know it is replaced by an altered state in which cognitive function is much reduced. A fish swimming in the sea regards the ocean as fixed and given; so we regard the normal state of consciousness. But it appears that in reality this normal state is a very "special state" which has been contrived in order for us to attend to perceptual events in space-time. Any considerable interference with that perceptual intake will shift consciousness into another state or mode. Such considerations suggest that not only is our normal state of consciousness a recent and specialized development, but that it is uniquely related to and sustained by the perceptual universe. If the rule works as well backward as forward, one wonders if the perceptual world of experience is not somehow related to and sustained by the collective consciousness which designs and observes it.

6. Let us look at the development of consciousness, that most

(page 382)

significant aspect of life. Consciousness has an irresistible tendency to form; for every level of consciousness therefore, there is a vehicle, of which the physical body is only one example. Satprem (1968:307) quotes Sri Aurobindo on this journey of consciousness:
 

If a spiritual unfolding on earth is the hidden truth of our birth into matter, if it is fundamentally an evolution of consciousness that is taking place in nature, then man, as he is, cannot be the last term in that evolution; he is too imperfect an expression of the spirit. Mind itself is too limited a form and instrumentation; mind is only a middle term of consciousness; the mental being can only be a transitional being.


The ordinary consciousness in the physical body tends to altered states of consciousness, and seems (as in the case of sleep) to require these intervals for proper rest and restoration. Tart (1971:3) says in this regard:
 

One of the most persistent and unusual aspects of human behavior . . . is man's dissatisfaction with the ordinary state of consciousness and the consequent development of innumerable methods of altering it.


The succession of conscious states is toward higher integration, not toward lower dissociation, toward more control of the environment, rather than less, and toward more grand perceptions of beneficence rather than toward the opposite. This principle is one of those facts (like the existence of the stars) which would be considered remarkable if we did not take it for granted. The process of integration in growth has the complementary virtues of being obvious in fact and transcendental in implication. It restores man from a reactive creature, differentiated in time to an integrated part of the noumenon. As Eliade 1969:199-200) says:
 

The ideal of yoga. . . . is to live in an eternal present, outside of time. The man, liberated in life, no longer possesses a personal consciousness. . . . but a witnessing consciousness, which is pure lucidity and spontaneity.


7. Regarding the three illusions:
 

a. The percepts of waking and dreaming (and hence all physical reality) are equally illusory, being governed by the generalized preconscious. This does not mean that the ordinary world of physical reality is without laws, but only that its supposed laws represent special cases of more general cosmic laws.

b. The consciousness of the ego as being bound in time and space

(page 383)
and as being in one point in that space-time is equally illusory. It is a kind of fiction invented to give us the experience of cognition and development, and hence the scenario of life is a self-designed dream.

c. The idea of the ego itself as a separate bit of consciousness is also an illusion. Human life is but the history of the growth, development, and diffusion of this illusion. In order to encourage the gradual transformation of this process it is useful to encourage the enhancement of self-concept from its initial narrow sense of "my body" to its ultimate broad sense of "my world," passing through the intermediate stages of my possessions, my loved ones, my work, my associations, and my creations.


The physical world is of course not unreal, but it is only a special case of the larger vivency of the collective unconscious into which our individual egos are launched to gain the experience of cognition and will in a time and space-bound world. We are held prisoner in this restricted space-time with its physical laws by our sense of ego, reinforced by what we call the "normal" state of consciousness. (Actually it is a very special state of consciousness in which intelligence is particularized). But even in our ego-consciousness we can escape the restrictive laws of the physical world into the larger laws of the metaphysical world by passing into an ASC.

8. Lama Govinda (1966:17) points out that (since the syntaxic mode embraces the lower modes as well) ". . . the essential nature of words is neither exhausted by their present meaning, nor is their importance confined to this usefulness as a transmitter of thought" -for they express at the same time qualities which are not translatable into concepts. He continues that it is precisely this parataxic quality in poetry and oratory which stirs us so deeply. This statement by the lama is indicative of the fact that the three cognitive modes are "epigenetic" in Erikson's sense - that is, each succeeding one builds on the previous, and contains it, although emphasizing a new and emergent aspect. He again senses this hierarchy in stating (Ibid) "If art can be called . . . the formal expression of reality . . . then the creation of language may be called the greatest achievement of art."

The same intuitive grasp of the hierarchy of the three modes is evidenced by Satprem (1964:60) in his biography of Sri Aurobindo when he declares, speaking of growing enlightenment: "Once in possession of these . . . the seeker begins to know . . . things as they are, for he no longer catches the external signs, gestures, all that immured dumb show, nor the veiled face of things, but the pure vibration in each thing . . ."
Satprem (1964:55) says further:

(page 384)

The task of the apprentice yogi ... is finally to become conscious in what men call death, for to the degree that we have been conscious in our life we shall become conscious in our death.
He (1964:103) quotes Sri Aurobindo as saying:
 
Matter is the starting point of our evolution; enclosed in it consciousness has gradually evolved; so the more consciousness emerges, the more it must recover its sovereignty and affirm its independence.
Finally he (1964:178) paraphrases Sri Aurobindo in stating:
 
Our sole problem is to lift ourselves to even higher planes by an individual evolution and our single life to transcribe and incarnate materially the truth of the plane to which we belong.


In a dream the perceptual events seem to be real, but actually are illusory, permuted about by unconscious forces, and the lucid dreamer knows that this is so, and that he is dreaming; in our normal state of consciousness, the percepts also seem to be real, but actually are equally illusory, being controlled and permuted by the collective unconscious, and the enlightened man like the lucid dreamer knows that this is so, and that he, too, is in reality in a dream. The dream state is to ordinary every-day "reality" as that reality is to ultimate reality; each state is the dream-state of the one above it.38

It appears that those who have successfully practiced the disciplines of the psychedelic stage and have reaped its enormous benefits fall into three classes. Curiously enough these categories are best delineated by another triple paradigm (Bruner's classification of concept formulation):
 

1. enactive (when the learning is in the muscles)
2. iconic (when the learning depends on signs [icons]
3. symbolic (when the learning has been completely integrated as a concept)


In the first two states, when the learning is less than fully complete symbolically, it can be approximated in the first instance through a system of body training (Hatha-yoga), and the following of ritual (such as Zen or alpha wave biofeedback), and in the second instance by recourse to icon-like archetypes which stand in the place of a concept which is too vague for complete cognitive formulation, but which indicates by a shadowy presence its substantive nature.

In the final instance, full psychedelic power is obtained, orthocognition is established, and the juncture of the conscious mind and the numinous element which presents itself as the collective preconscious

(page 385)

brings not only creativity and serendipity, but literally the positive control of all aspects of man's self-concept from body-image outward to complete altruism. This "heaven on earth" "Omega point" is a literal re-establishment of the pristine Adamic estate, at present glimpsed only in ecstasies and visions. It is contained, of course, within the "durative topocosm" which exists throughout time, and waits only on man's developing mind to again bring it to physical manifestation. It is in this concept that psychology comes to aid man in understanding what was formerly called "the mystic path" in a more modern and useful way.

10. When we reflect on the enormous loss to the psyche when it leaves the state of the numinous element and dips into space-time and the existence of an individual ego, there must be some counter-vailing advantage to this perilous descent into mortality and finiteness. That advantage is clearly the cognitive consciousness, whose possession gives not only the opportunity to observe and experience nature, but also to co-design the world of experience. It is this latter opportunity which is the precious one, for it takes the conscious will to direct the numinous element to manifest events.

Let us remember that human life is but the projection of a greater individuality into the restricted cognitive ego, bound into space-time, where it takes a flight through the eight developmental stages, hopefully to return again to the Spacious Now, having completed the developmental cycle in ego- integrity and altruism. Presumably, this process is to gain the cognitive experience which this life affords as an added facet of the larger individuality. But consider some of the difficulties that can befall during this mortal interlude. For one thing, the ego may get enmeshed in mortality, arrested in the developmental process and fail to complete it, thus being consigned (as the Bardo Thodol tells us), to an endless recyclement until it breaks out of its circle. But there is an inverse peril for those who become developed. It is that the individuality, while still in its ego dream, will become enough enlightened to understand that the laws of physics which govern the space-time world are only a special case of the laws of metaphysics which govern the domain of the Eternal Now.

We have called this partial awakening orthocognition, and like the lucid dream (in which the dreamer knows he is dreaming) this insight gives the option of conscious use of the expanded laws of metaphysics to the still partly selfish ego-consciousness; in short the creative man gains psychedelic powers over his environment. The danger of not renouncing the world before we gain power to transcend it is that we will never want to renounce it at all, and that the

(page 386)

individuality in the diminished form of an incompletely developed ego will trap itself in a garden of earthly delights. This is why true mystics would rather endure suffering than suffer the temptation of enjoyment. It is also why orthocognition, despite its wakening powers, should be used with wise restraint. For power corrupts, and we must be sure before we use it that our hearts and desires are pure. A worse fate than not getting one's desire is to get it and find it was the wrong thing to have in the first place.

11. At intervals during this ordinary-reality dream, certain aspects of the psyche gain the upper hand, so that the ego (either in trance or meditation) does not pay attention to ordinary reality. When this happens, the larger individuality takes over, and the person is not bound by the laws of ordinary reality. Hence, these people during this situation (which we call dissociation or trance), may walk on fire, levitate, prophesy, become clairvoyant and telepathic, and influence nature directly to name some of the more important examples. To be sure, in the prototaxic mode, these effects can be accomplished only by the temporary exclusion of the ego (which because of its reality-relating properties could not tolerate consciousness under these circumstances). But in the syntaxic mode when the ego expands to greater understanding, it can be allowed to remain though with various degrees of light dissociation. The proper function of altered states of consciousness, which allow the operation of the laws of non-ordinary reality, is to permit the conscious ego to design and order the natural events or ordinary reality in harmony with goodness.

It is the business of the ego to attend to ordinary reality; it is the business of other parts of the psyche to relate to non-ordinary reality, that is, the noumenon outside our space and time. While we may look at our ordinary reality as "real," it is actually the other way around, for it is non-ordinary reality that is the ultimate real. Actually the laws of physics in our ordinary reality are only a special case of the laws of metaphysics in non-ordinary reality, for our ordinary reality is but a special and restricted area in the larger domain, with special and restricted laws. During our little life here, the ego appears as an artifact of the eight developmental stages, rising in the first and setting in the last, in order to gain cognition and will in a space-time-bound situation, hopefully to return to the Eternal Now fortified with the cognitive experience gained here. But all the while the real existence of the individuality is in the Spacious Present of Non-ordinary reality.

12. Suppose it is determined that the best way for the numinous element (which appears to us in a present state of hypnotized and unindividualized subjective preconsciousness) to gain rational

(page 387)

consciousness is to project a series of nascent individualized egos into time-space experience. There, hopefully, they develop, effloresce, and eventually return to the undifferentiated spirit fortified with the jeweled experience of initiation and selection in will and consciousness. (At least this is one way of looking at it for us in the dream.) This, then, is the experience which we call life.

Our egos are ephemeral, transitory events, which develop (like waves), effloresce, and diffuse, carrying back with them to the Spirit which originated them the precious experience of rational consciousness. This individualized process is carried out in eight stages of development, discovered by Erikson:

in stage 1, the ego is absent;
in stage 2, it rises and differentiates;
in stage 3, it explores love of self and parents;
in stage 4, it stops trying to make people and starts trying to make things;
in stage 5, it reaches its zenith of separatism in the adolescent identity- crisis;
in stage 6, it begins diffusion in love of the beloved and in creativity;
in stage 7, it further diffuses in parental succorance, and psychedelic experiences;
in stage 8, it sets in illumination, knowing that its destiny is to transcend self;
in stage 9, it is again absent.


The central issue in the development of man is the relationship between the generalized impersonal mind (which we call the preconscious) and the particularized conscious manifestation of it (which we call our individual consciousness). Each of these aspects of intelligence brings to their psychedelic union its own peculiar and characteristic powers, and each needs the support of the other. The generalized mind, which exists in a hypnotized impersonal state has genie-like powers over the environment including ourselves, but lacks conscious will and personality. The particular conscious mind has the regnancy of individual will, consciousness, and rational thought, but lacks the generalized powers, which can only be wisely and usefully released in a union of the two (which we call the psychedelic state).

In the unitive state, these two aspects are joined; and as in a closed electrical circuit, the current flows, empowering the human consciousness with quasi-divine authority, and humanizing the impersonal preconscious with the rationalizing of human conscious evaluation in place of the dark archetypes of the collective subconscious. To be sure, not all these methods are of equal value, for some allow for much more rational control than others, and it is this rational control of the process which is the continuum on which they should be evaluated.

To the extent that each individual human mind shares in the generalized preconscious, it becomes a creator, just as the generalized preconscious is. Therefore, every human has the potentiality of

(page 388)

creation, not just of ideas but of actual reality; and from this it follows that whatever people believe in, becomes real in an existential sense. The enormous implications of this concept, (which among other things solves the problem of the origin of evil) are extremely important for each of us to understand, so that we do not, by negative thoughts, add to the sum total of evil in the world, but instead contribute to its opposite - the good.

The numinous element appears in the process of becoming, in the process of manifesting, in the process of building, toward what is to us a future event of perfection. All that precedes that dawn is prologue, including the dream world in which we live, for this can be conceptualized as no more than the numinous element trying out different facets of its power and energy through the medium of our individualized lives, much as a concert artist tries out themes before a symphony concert. But that rehearsal is a necessary part of its evolution, for when housed in us, it is able, if but in the blink of a man's lifetime, to blend its awesome power with the personal element which it alone lacks: it is able in a finite life to become complete, and to pre-figure the "far-off Divine event" of the poet, when all having been brought to perfection, the All will fully cognize the All. Thus each individual life is part of an eternal prologue in which the numinous element is being perfected and completed to a new and more glorious dawn. Thoreau, that rustic seer, said of this process: "That day is yet to dawn, for the sun is only a morning star!"
 

LIBERATION

Imprisoned thricely by the walls
Of time, space, and personage,
When shall we heed the voice that calls
To tell us of our lineage?
It rises silent as a spring
Within the quiet of the mind;
It is a different sort of thing;
It bids us leave the world behind.
In time's cocoon we swing asleep,
Perchance a lucid dream tonight
To will begone the pupal deep
And wing the butterfly aflight.
Arise my soul and seek thee now
The glory of the noumenon;
For thou art That, and That art thou;
So from thy fetters hence begone.
Man is not dust; he comes afar
And recognizes not his home.
Our sun is but the morning star
To that celestial dawn to come.
Oh Spirit, that has made us bold
To think such thoughts in lieu of Thee,
Make manifest in men untold
This avenue to liberty.


(page 389)

FOOTNOTES

1. This statement is true of the current scene. But time-transcendence may yet prove amenable to scientific investigation. The slowing-down and speeding-up of time at speeds approaching the velocity of light offer physical indication of its relativistic nature.

2. To be discussed in Section 4.5.

3. See Section 4.5.

4. For a good discussion of the siddhis, see Eliade 1969:178ff.

5. For example, consult Le Shan 1974, Ferguson 1974; Hammond 1973.

6. Eliade 1969:328-332 discusses the production of psychic heat in shamans and yogins.

7. The Nobel Prize novelist, Herman Hesse also wrote of such matters in Sparkenbrokeand Siddartha.

8. For further discussion of psychic sound see Eliade 1969:390.

9. But possibly not the original meaning. The principal obscene English verb goes back a long way to the Sanscrit "phat" (to fertilize or beget) which root appears in the Latin verb "to be" (sum, ease, fui), in the participle "futurus" (from which we get "future"- to be begot into being), and the Italian fiat (let it be begot or made). The existence of the three stems: 1) sum (I am), (c.f. sacred mantra "aum"),  2) esse (essence, being) and  3) fuiin the three principal parts of the Latin verb "to be" is curious. There is even an isomorphism between this verb and "to know"; both in their finality result in being and becoming (see sect. 4.84). The surface trace of this isomorphism is seen in the fact that in the ancient and carnal sense the two verbs are synonyms.

10. Since our Western views of tantra are so liable to error, we urge our readers to consult Blofeld (1970) or Eliade 1969:232ff which contain extensive discussions. The latter cite discusses the production

(page 390)

of psychic heat by the kundalini ascent, and mentions that "this heat is transmuted sexual energy." "The tantric ideal is to achieve simultaneous immobility of breath, thought, and semen" (Eliade 1969:248).

11. e.g. Sodium is to potassium as Spain is to Portugal.

12. Previous six paragraphs from Gowan (1972), copyright by R. Knapp Co and used by permission.

13. This section has been abstracted from the M. A. thesis of graduate student, Debby Zeff.

14. This section and the next are from Gowan (1972) copyright by R. Knapp Co. and used by permission.

15. In fairness, it should be noted that while this statement from the text is accurate with regard to the initial emphasis of the Buffalo Creative-Problem Solving Workshop, during the 1970's, under the enlightened direction of Sidney Parnes, it has devoted increasing attention to creativity as psychological openness, as may be seen by its use of this volume as a text for the 21st workshop.

16. (See note 12)

17. (See note 12)

18. The author wishes to acknowledge with thanks the kindness of Dr. Stanley Krippner, the leading expert in this area, in permitting this extensive quotation from his 1972 article.

19. The first eight paragraphs are quoted from Krippner (1972).

20. See section 3.36 for further material.

21. For Dodd's Epicosm Model see the Appendix.

22. This section is due to graduate student Nancy Donaldson. For update on this subject, consult Barber and others (1970), Stoyva and others (1971). Shapiro and others (1972), and Miller and others (1973). These Aldine Annuals come out each year. See also the extensive bibliography on alpha and biofeedback in Ferguson 1973:88ff, 347, 352-5.

23. This topic, which has obvious connections with healing, is well documented: see Barber and others 1970:351- 447, Stoyva and others 1971:245-283, Shapiro and others 1972:191-253, and Miller and others, 1973:295-363.

24. This section is due to graduate student Nancy Donaldson.

25. Here has been removed a lengthy section giving the pros and cons of this subject, which it was felt would not be interesting to the general reader.

26. We hazard the guess that it may also be emitted through the feet, and perhaps even the genitals. It is suggestive that hands and feet contain acupuncture points for the whole body, and that there are traditions that highly evolved persons may be recognized by the

(page 391)

perfection of their hands and feet. For other special aspects of the extremities, see note 6 Table III.

27. Satprem (1968): has coined the word "entasy" as an anonym to "extasy" (ecstasy). If exsto, exstare, exstavi, exstatus, means "to stand outside," then ensto, enstare, enstavi, enstatus, would mean "to stand inside."

28. This idea was given me by James Beggs in a personal communication.

29. The author acknowledges the help of Bill Zika in the preparation of this section.

30. For an elementary treatise on this writer, see Donnelly (1956). For zealous students, Satprem (1968) is perhaps the best. Aurobindo himself is difficult reading.

31. And hence fraught with less siddhis and less psychic danger.

32. Suggested to me by John Whiteside.

33. This effect was pointed out to me by Barbara Hubbard who has observed it as a phenomenon of her SYNCON conventions.

34. For this and higher jhanas, see Eliade 1969:170ff.

35. See Eliade 1969:272.

36. Maslow (Kepes 1966:134-143) glimpsed this concept in his article, "Isomorphic relationship between knower and known."

37. A very recent psychological survey of American mystical experience comes to attention as we go to press. It is The Sociology of Mystic Ecstasy by A. M. Greeley and W. C. McCready (National Opinion Research Center), Chicago, (mimeo.), n.d. (abstracted in Newsletter Review 7:1:61-65, Spr. 1974, R. M. Backe Memorial Soc'y. 4453 Maisonneuve Blvd. Montreal 215, Quebec). With an N of 1467, 60% had felt in touch with an absent person, and 39% had had a response experience, the most common triggers being aesthetic, religious, and sexual. Peak ages were 20 and 35, and the occurrence was correlated with socio-economic class indicators as with Laski's research. Moreover they tend to be highly intelligent, creative, and in good mental health.

38. When humans are in a "developmental front" between two states of consciousness, they experience the phenomenon that the state toward which the development is moving first comes rarely and transiently and for just a few moments (nature-mystic experience). As one progresses (or in schizophrenia, retrogresses), the state comes more frequently and lasts longer. It becomes habitual, and finally permanent (or nearly so), which is what has happened here in the higher jhanas.

39. A hertz (hz) is one cycle per second.

40. This late cite is not in bibliography. (Ph.D. United States International University, San Diego, 1974. Write Dr. Charlotte Malone, 7121 Wandermere Dr. San Diego CA, 92119).